Abu Ali case :: Reader comments at Daniel Pipes

Submitted by Darwin S. Stamper (Panama), Mar 1, 2005 at 20:33

If this Abu Ali was tortured and beaten with a whip it should be verifyable by scars on his back. I read that a doctor examined him and said he had not been whipped.

What is the truth? Why don´t we see more about the medical exam in the papers? If Abu Ali did indeed take part in the planning of terrorist strikes in Saudi Arabis where nine of his countrymen died and he plotted to kill Americans he is guilty of treason against this county. yet, I hear no one mention the crime of treason.

Like Dislike

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>

Reader comments (60) on this item

	Title	Commenter	Date	Thread
	wrong [125 words]	The Truth	Mar 7, 2008 14:25	121999
1	re: Kazi's comments [655 words]	Maxx	Oct 31, 2005 20:54	27566
	In reply to Octavio Johanson [238 words]	Peter J. Herz	Mar 23, 2005 05:39	21136
	Support of terrorists [89 words]	Donvan	Mar 17, 2005 16:59	21045
	The price of liberty [61 words]	S.C.Panda	Mar 17, 2005 04:25	21036
	Moderate Muslims [180 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes	Kazi	Mar 15, 2005 16:09	21003
	The State's reason for existing [78 words]	Dogzilla	Mar 9, 2005 20:02	20934
	The real danger to US national security [251 words]	B. Alotaibi	Mar 8, 2005 13:25	20871
	that is wrong [67 words]	A Muslim Girl	Oct 18, 2007 22:07	20871
	Security, Civil Rights or Propaganda [159 words]	John	Mar 6, 2005 16:18	20707
	Abu Ali case [126 words]	Reuben Ingber	Mar 6, 2005 07:40	20702
	More info on ISA [335 words]	Ada Evans	Mar 4, 2005 19:46	20665
	Liberals and Conservatives both to blame [271 words]	Mark Garretson	Mar 4, 2005 15:35	20663
	Definition of treason? [50 words]	Patricia Kelcher	Mar 4, 2005 12:15	20661
	Inshallah [686 words]	Dr. Jamshid Ibrahim	Mar 4, 2005 06:55	20656
	Hatred taught to Muslim youth [93 words]	A. Woods	Mar 3, 2005 17:50	20650
	Reform civil liberties and control immigration [140 words]	Octavio Johanson	Mar 3, 2005 16:29	20648
	Al Qaeda coached to claim torture... [167 words]	L. D. Weiner	Mar 3, 2005 14:55	20647
	Defeating terrorism [551 words]	Derek Bernard	Mar 3, 2005 13:22	20645
	Balance [296 words]	Dan Katcher	Mar 3, 2005 12:46	20644
	Time to abandon multi-culturalism [140 words]	Octavio Johanson	Mar 3, 2005 08:01	20642
	Did 9/11 in fact "more profoundly affect" conservatives than it did liberals? [35 words]	Jonathan Rick	Mar 3, 2005 00:40	20640
	Silent terrorists within [52 words]	Richard I. Ellis	Mar 2, 2005 23:55	20639
	Libs. & Cons. PROFOUNDLY DERANGED [119 words]	Chayajane	Mar 2, 2005 22:21	20638
	Bull's Eye! [85 words]	Jeremy Rabkin	Mar 2, 2005 20:17	20634
	Relax [301 words]	Werner de Rocqer	Mar 2, 2005 19:34	20633
	Let the courts decide [89 words]	David J. Bastyr	Mar 2, 2005 17:19	20632
	I choose SECURITY [140 words]	Tony Figueroa	Mar 2, 2005 15:21	20631
	Mistakes [43 words]	Robert Patterson	Mar 2, 2005 14:32	20629
	Deportation [151 words]	Octavio Johanson	Mar 2, 2005 14:20	20628
	WHY! [231 words]	Paul Rinderle	Mar 2, 2005 14:14	20627
	Your correct appraisal of 'Liberalism'.. [80 words]	Nitsuard	Mar 2, 2005 14:12	20626
	We share your fears. [125 words]	K. A. Khan	Mar 2, 2005 12:32	20622
	Politics and the actual law [146 words]	Chad DesLauriers	Mar 2, 2005 12:16	20621
	Training on US soil [82 words]	Wilks	Mar 2, 2005 10:17	20619
	Article on Balancing Liberaties [36 words]	Annette Hughes	Mar 2, 2005 09:57	20618
	The problem is that the Saudis can get away with anything! [208 words]	Kenneth S. Besig	Mar 2, 2005 06:34	20617
	The Abu Ali Case and] Balancing Liberties, Security [29 words]	Rachelle Assouline-Seynaeve	Mar 2, 2005 05:21	20616
	Black or white fallacy [61 words]	Nick Good	Mar 2, 2005 04:14	20615
	Hmmmmm. [36 words]	Peter J. Herz	Mar 1, 2005 23:26	20610
	Abu... we hardly knew yeh? [88 words]	Donald O	Mar 1, 2005 23:00	20609
	Life or Liberty [535 words]	Arlinda DeAngelis	Mar 1, 2005 21:41	20604
	The Abu Ali Case [1 words]	Edward Mamet	Mar 1, 2005 21:18	20601
	I am with you, Mr. Pipes [78 words]	Carol McLaughlin	Mar 1, 2005 21:09	20600
	They don't get it [141 words]	Rob	Mar 1, 2005 20:49	20599
	Abu Ali case [96 words]	Darwin S. Stamper	Mar 1, 2005 20:33	20598
	Impaled on the horns of a very big dilemma [274 words]	Darwin Barrett	Mar 1, 2005 19:52	20596
	Seeds of our destruction [28 words]	Sam Richter MD	Mar 1, 2005 19:41	20595
	American Protection from Terrorist Threat [41 words]	Charles J Paine	Mar 1, 2005 18:25	20593
	Blind [342 words]	Donald W. Bales	Mar 1, 2005 18:22	20592
	Forget about civil liberties [169 words]	Octavio Johanson	Mar 1, 2005 18:19	20591
	Exactly right Mr. Pipes [123 words]	Paul Rhoads	Mar 1, 2005 17:59	20589
	Frightening! [36 words]	Nathan Roth	Mar 1, 2005 17:41	20588
	Has Bush hatred gone so far that we feel no outrage? [72 words]	Northern Virginiastan	Mar 1, 2005 17:04	20587
	Accurate [45 words]	Jeremiah J. Spires	Mar 1, 2005 16:57	20586
	Liberals are losing their brains [45 words]	basha	Mar 1, 2005 16:32	20585
	A necessary choice [41 words]	Herbert B. Borteck	Mar 1, 2005 16:30	20583
	Freedom First [304 words]	Pat	Mar 1, 2005 16:25	20582
	The press and propaganda re Abu Ali [54 words]	S. Vladimer LTC USAR Ret	Mar 1, 2005 15:55	20581
	Another Way of Assessing the Question [405 words]	Leonard Deutchman	Mar 1, 2005 15:15	20579