69 million page views

Are the palestinians a "people"

Reader comment on item: Is There a Palestinian People? Can It be Defeated?

Submitted by Richard Martin (China), Jan 28, 2017 at 01:23

For someone I have great respect for, your illogic in making your argument that yes, the palestinians are a people, saddens me.

A "people" requires that people having certain things. First a history. The dates you use are basically current event dates that have no historial meaning. The 1960s is just behind the corner of time and using to justify a "history" is not Historical.

Secondly, a people must have a uniqueness that disassociates themselves from other people. Those unique qualities woud include a language, cultural unique qualities such as dress, cuisine, customs, etc. Thirdly- and here we return to a real "history", they must have their own writers, artists, kings or leaders, proof of certain "facts' such as currency, historical buildings found in places that remained under their authority and control and under their leadership.

Kurds have those unique facts, palestinians do not. Their relationship to the land of Israel is that of migratory tenant farmers who would move to the land and leave the land when a combination of Ottoman taxation and Bedouin banditry made farming a hopeless endeavor.

Why did so many of them refer to themselves as 'southern Syrians"? because that is where they were from. They never maintained any committment to the land of Israel until the Zionist movement brought Jews and those Jews werable to create the one thing that no Arab anywhere could create. Jobs. Thus palestinians are economic migrants from various Arab entities that border on Israel.

And they never called themselves palestinians for another very good reason. That was the name used by Jews to describe themselves and what self respecting Arab would use the same name that Jews used for him/her self.

Illegal Mexicans in the Southwest US have a greater claim to being there than palestinians have to being in Israel. And when Jews were told by the Mandate authorities starting in the 1930's that the land was "full up and could not sustain any more people" can you tell me how many "palestinians: were trucked into Israel during WW II to help with the British war effort?

And why did the UN create a special definition of a "palestinian" that applies only to them and is different from all others which prove a person belongs to the land he is claiming? Becasue very few palestinians had any constant relation to the land of Israel which is the basic for their claims.

Mr. Pipes, there was outrage to your finding that the Arabs in Israel are a unique people because they fail all the traditional tests which would identify them as such. And I find it embarrassing that you use such recent dates to shore up your argument.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Daniel Pipes replies:

First, I said 1920, not the 1960s. But more important is the basic rule that if a group considers itself a people, it is one. That's the only objective definition. By this rule, the Palestinians do make the cut as a people, however belligerent they are.

Submit a comment on this item

Reader comments (24) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Now [49 words]AlbertE.Jan 31, 2017 22:51236154
2Israel keeps losing the Public Relations war in America [208 words]Concerned from USAJan 30, 2017 08:25236066
You are totally correct. Israels P.R. lacks much. [487 words]SilverwolfApr 17, 2017 12:33236066
Are palestinians a people [619 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Richard MartinJan 28, 2017 23:01235952
Palestinans a people and can they be defeated/ [494 words]Richard MartinJan 28, 2017 02:31235914
Are palestinians a "people" an addtional comment [334 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Richard MartinJan 28, 2017 01:47235913
response to Daniel Pipes [419 words]Richard MartinJan 29, 2017 06:57235913
Are the palestinians a "people" [449 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Richard MartinJan 28, 2017 01:23235912
3The two nations states of 'British Palestine' are the State of Israel and Kingdom of Jordan. [37 words]AVJan 15, 2017 18:16235396
More details please [82 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
PezDispenserJan 15, 2017 13:32235392
Is there a Palestinian People? [14 words]dianne gallenJan 14, 2017 17:34235369
1Gypsies, Jews, Nationalism, and The American People [219 words]RobertJan 12, 2017 20:46235306
What About King Abdullah of Jordan's Contention [126 words]M. ToveyJan 12, 2017 15:30235297
3Worldwide alert: the real Arab Muslim mission! [907 words]YJ DraimanJan 12, 2017 05:05235293
Jerusalem [38 words]AnonJan 11, 2017 23:29235292
Are Palestinians a People [208 words]Liatris SpicataJan 11, 2017 21:28235288
Palestinian Arabs are Not "THE Palestinians" [189 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Jerome R VerlinJan 11, 2017 17:08235286
1The "Palestinian" identity is a veil, therefore an illusion [285 words]AnonJan 11, 2017 16:01235284
A few comments [178 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Ephraim LiorJan 11, 2017 14:16235281
The Russian dezinformatsia created the Palestinian People in 1964 [164 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Wallace BrandJan 11, 2017 12:11235279
Is There a Palestinian People [68 words]emil shehadehJan 11, 2017 11:55235278
Obstacles To Victory [180 words]DaveJan 11, 2017 11:46235277
Capital, political unit, state ect ect: these are all Western concepts with no relevance for indigenous people [15 words]SPJan 11, 2017 10:48235276
WWIII is on the way, and will not be late. [363 words]Michael SJan 11, 2017 04:50235268

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)