| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
dhimmi: Letter to Julanda brothers fact or fiction?
Reader comment on item: [The Islamist-Leftist] Allied Menace
in response to reader comment: Islam and its origin
Submitted by Plato (India), Jul 12, 2008 at 01:21
Hello dhimmi no more,
You wrote:
>>The only sources we have about the origin of Islam from Muslims are literary sources written by non-Arabs in distant Mesopotamia in the 3rd century of islam. There are no coins, papyri, epigraphy or anyhting that is extant and can tell us about this religion. Nothing. Not a thing.<<
There is supposed to be a letter written by Muhammad to the Juland brothers kept in a fort in Sohar. Have you heard of it? How genuine do you think it is? http://www.answering-islam.org/Muhammad/oman.htm
Warm regards
Plato
Dislike
Submitting....
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (150) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Islamist-Leftist nexus [170 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Prashant | Nov 3, 2012 02:20 | 200262 | ||
| Corruptions of Biblical Faith [113 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Kepha Hor | Nov 2, 2012 22:47 | 200261 | ||
 Looking Past the Corruption to See the Truth in Biblical Faith [297 words] | M Tovey | Jul 15, 2021 13:45 | 200261 | ||
| It's 1939 revisited [52 words] | Lujack Skylark | Nov 2, 2012 15:25 | 200254 | ||
| far left german mps on ship stopped by IDF [106 words] | myth | Jun 1, 2010 16:59 | 173682 | ||
| Islam and Marxism not Partners [275 words] | Marian Hennings | Apr 19, 2010 02:10 | 171441 | ||
| It's a classic alignment [15 words] | larkascending | Feb 11, 2010 07:46 | 168782 | ||
| illogical mind-set of the west!!! [319 words] | annam a | Jun 19, 2009 05:56 | 157632 | ||
| Small mistake [23 words] | Mike Love | Sep 5, 2008 02:49 | 137954 | ||
| the islamist leftist allied menace [22 words] | joe | Aug 20, 2008 14:13 | 137073 | ||
| throwing rocks in glass houses? [140 words] | Larry B. | Aug 12, 2008 21:13 | 136636 | ||
| Liberals couldn't hit the broad side of a barn [281 words] | jennifer solis | Aug 14, 2008 15:16 | 136636 | ||
| time will tell [75 words] | larry B | Aug 18, 2008 20:38 | 136636 | ||
| the world doesn't need new Chamberlains [373 words] | Staunch Secularism Supporter | Jul 31, 2008 02:49 | 135953 | ||
| Birds of a feather flock together [73 words] | TruthAloneTriumphs | Jul 30, 2008 05:55 | 135900 | ||
| Bravo, Dr Pipes ! [83 words] | Anne-Marie Delcambre | Jul 19, 2008 08:44 | 135392 | ||
| 2 | Bravo Geert Wilders and Dr.Pipes [77 words] | Tony Sytsma | Jun 30, 2010 20:15 | 135392 | |
| Putin and his buddies [107 words] | Ugri | Jul 17, 2008 12:03 | 135331 | ||
| Liberalism and Islam: The Hijacking of America's Schools [88 words] | John Marion | Jul 15, 2008 16:10 | 135227 | ||
| That will be the day ! [184 words] | dfwhite19438 | Jul 13, 2008 21:26 | 135011 | ||
| Congratulations President Sarkozy [56 words] | PDM | Jul 13, 2008 12:41 | 134994 | ||
| all the left? [78 words] | obilic | Jul 11, 2008 11:10 | 134876 | ||
| The left and generalizing [388 words] | Straight_Talk_Luigi | Jul 11, 2008 19:46 | 134876 | ||
| Can't happen here? All we have to do is nothing. [81 words] | Sofa Sogood | Jul 12, 2008 01:36 | 134876 | ||
| Straight_Talk_Luigi, what do you mean? [43 words] | Infidel | Jul 13, 2008 02:25 | 134876 | ||
| Blasting the Islamic call for prayer? [383 words] | Edward | Jul 14, 2008 02:38 | 134876 | ||
| Response to Infidel's Question [47 words] | Straight_Talk_Luigi | Jul 14, 2008 16:15 | 134876 | ||
| noise pollution [128 words] | dfwhite19438 | Jul 14, 2008 22:23 | 134876 | ||
| Dear dfwhite19438 [325 words] | Edward | Jul 15, 2008 01:15 | 134876 | ||
| Straight_Talk_Luigi, error in typing, not knowledge [75 words] | Infidel | Jul 16, 2008 22:20 | 134876 | ||
| 1 | islam hate of others. [166 words] | surj | Jul 28, 2008 17:41 | 134876 | |
| Hatred for others [335 words] | Edward | Jul 31, 2008 01:51 | 134876 | ||
| Myopically educated [264 words] | Larry B. | Aug 12, 2008 21:42 | 134876 | ||
| Reason?.. [197 words] | DONVAN | Aug 21, 2008 10:03 | 134876 | ||
| Qur'an is NOT obscure. It is very understandable and rich. [45 words] | Edward | Aug 23, 2008 06:51 | 134876 | ||
| interesting.. [80 words] | donvan | Aug 24, 2008 12:22 | 134876 | ||
| Still the same [30 words] | Edward | Aug 25, 2008 01:16 | 134876 | ||
| Islamic call for prayer - Kampala, Uganda [203 words] | Scott | Feb 20, 2009 14:48 | 134876 | ||
| Islamic call for prayer in kampala [311 words] | Edward | Feb 22, 2009 23:46 | 134876 | ||
| Prayers in Kampala [118 words] | Scott | Feb 23, 2009 18:32 | 134876 | ||
| 1 | Controversial Alliances Found in the Holy Bible's Alignment of Nations Against Israel [406 words] | M. Tovey | Jul 9, 2008 14:01 | 134720 | |
| Sure? [16 words] | Ynnatchkah | Jul 11, 2008 01:45 | 134720 | ||
| amazing Revelation [131 words] | Rebecca Moulds | Jul 11, 2008 07:15 | 134720 | ||
| Ishmael descendants. [79 words] | Ynnatchkah | Jul 11, 2008 12:27 | 134720 | ||
| Positive, According to the Word of the LORD [49 words] | M. Tovey | Jul 14, 2008 10:32 | 134720 | ||
| In the Face of the Aliied Menace [71 words] | M. Tovey | Jul 14, 2008 10:56 | 134720 | ||
| Ishmael, Like as a Child of Egypt-To be Brought Under Submission to Israel-The True Son of the Promise [443 words] | M. Tovey | Jul 14, 2008 11:33 | 134720 | ||
| israelites [88 words] | Ahmed Khota | Jul 24, 2008 08:46 | 134720 | ||
| Faith in the Almighty God of Israel is Not a Religion - Read and Believe the Holy Bible [129 words] | M. Tovey | Jul 29, 2008 19:44 | 134720 | ||
| Adding to Admonitions After Thirteen Years - What Islamism has not Learned [121 words] | M Tovey | Apr 16, 2021 12:27 | 134720 | ||
| 4 | Many thanks to brave people to have helped my father escape from Iran . [274 words] | zari namdar | Jul 8, 2008 03:45 | 134622 | |
| Stockhausen quote [39 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | dominic | Jul 7, 2008 01:29 | 134533 | ||
| you forgot india [43 words] | PM | Jul 6, 2008 04:20 | 134487 | ||
| Criucial Position of India in the Balance of Powers [46 words] | Singha | Jul 8, 2008 04:12 | 134487 | ||
| Not entirely [53 words] | Devasahayam | Jul 8, 2008 09:13 | 134487 | ||
| Singha [37 words] | PM | Jul 9, 2008 17:13 | 134487 | ||
| As I stated before [57 words] | Devasahayam | Jul 10, 2008 20:16 | 134487 | ||
| agree. [18 words] | surj | Jul 28, 2008 18:03 | 134487 | ||
| The problem of ignorance [117 words] | Rebecca Moulds | Jul 5, 2008 21:14 | 134477 | ||
| Collusion [640 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Nadia Furlan | Jul 5, 2008 14:10 | 134464 | |
| Leftists and Islam [104 words] | Peter Herz | Jul 5, 2008 07:14 | 134439 | ||
| Sovietto Leftist Gobbledeegook. Does Tolerance Mean Tolerance of Intolerance? Inversion of Reality. [395 words] | Sofa Sogood | Jul 4, 2008 23:55 | 134421 | ||
| The Reds are active everywhere [164 words] | Peter Edgar | Jul 4, 2008 08:09 | 134379 | ||
| 1 | Leftists are COWARDS [131 words] | jennifer solis | Jul 4, 2008 01:17 | 134347 | |
| Dear Jennifer [339 words] | Straight_Talk_Luigi | Jul 4, 2008 14:36 | 134347 | ||
| Situation in France [337 words] | Georges | Jul 4, 2008 17:08 | 134347 | ||
| a portend of frightening degrees [199 words] | Rebecca Moulds | Jul 7, 2008 16:56 | 134347 | ||
| a portend of frightening degrees [571 words] | Georges | Jul 7, 2008 18:55 | 134347 | ||
| Romans and Liberals [295 words] | jennfer solis | Jul 8, 2008 17:23 | 134347 | ||
| more of the same [436 words] | Rebecca Moulds | Jul 8, 2008 17:28 | 134347 | ||
| For Jennifer, Name Calling and Liberals [596 words] | Straight_Talk_Luigi | Jul 8, 2008 18:21 | 134347 | ||
| LEFTISTS ARE COWARD MENTIONED BY JENNIFER SOLIS [47 words] | Tirdad Gharib | Jul 11, 2008 08:59 | 134347 | ||
| tooting for the oil barons? [176 words] | Larry B. | Aug 12, 2008 22:02 | 134347 | ||
| Pres.Clinton cut our military in half [46 words] | jennifer solis | Aug 13, 2008 15:17 | 134347 | ||
| 1 | Live Example and proof of ISLAMOCOMMUNISM - West Bengal, India [288 words] | Simon B | Jul 3, 2008 01:57 | 134258 | |
| These are not strange bedfellows at all [190 words] | Surak | Jul 2, 2008 20:03 | 134237 | ||
| Response and addtional discussion on leftist/islamist alliance [230 words] | Straight_Talk_Luigi | Jul 4, 2008 00:39 | 134237 | ||
| Strange Bedfellows Indeed [94 words] | M. Tovey | Jul 2, 2008 19:21 | 134229 | ||
| Is it really though? [114 words] | Straight_Talk_Luigi | Jul 4, 2008 00:33 | 134229 | ||
| Communism and Islam: what they also have or had in common. [27 words] | Steven L | Jul 2, 2008 18:24 | 134222 | ||
| The Islamist-Leftist] Allied Menace [134 words] | Ellen Schneider | Jul 2, 2008 15:32 | 134203 | ||
| Ellen Schneider, brilliant evil people [160 words] | Infidel | Jul 3, 2008 00:15 | 134203 | ||
| brilliant evil people [102 words] | Ellen Schneider | Jul 3, 2008 22:18 | 134203 | ||
| Planes Into Buildings -- Not So Brilliant. Perniciously Turning Us Against Ourselves Is More So. [744 words] | Sofa Sogood | Jul 4, 2008 00:22 | 134203 | ||
| Ellen Schneider, Evil is not Brilliant [155 words] | Infidel | Jul 4, 2008 12:29 | 134203 | ||
| Response to Sofa Sogood's comment: [The Islamist-Leftist] Allied Menace [363 words] | Ellen Schneider | Jul 4, 2008 14:07 | 134203 | ||
| PRAY FOR PEACE BUT PREPARE FOR WAR .(MILITARY ACTION WILL SOON DESTROY AHMADINEJAD AND ALL THE ISLAMIC TERRRORISTS [178 words] | TIRDAD GHARIB | Jul 2, 2008 14:23 | 134199 | ||
| Most Certainly [74 words] | MJT | Jul 2, 2008 13:50 | 134197 | ||
| "What Sir Malcolm Sargent thought of it" [43 words] | Barry Holroyd | Jul 2, 2008 10:04 | 134184 | ||
| Sir Malcolm Sargent [90 words] | Gabby | Jul 10, 2008 06:56 | 134184 | ||
| Dr. Pipes Artile - Missing "C" Word [460 words] | Singha | Jul 2, 2008 00:29 | 134146 | ||
| China and Islam [106 words] | Peter Herz | Jul 5, 2008 07:06 | 134146 | ||
| Eritrea and the Islamist-Leftist alliance [147 words] | Rob | Jul 2, 2008 00:16 | 134144 | ||
| Obama...? [33 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | David Aronin | Jul 1, 2008 19:24 | 134113 | ||
| Almost concur with Dr. Pipes [13 words] | Devasahayam | Jul 9, 2008 15:47 | 134113 | ||
| 3 | Che Guevara's children in Iran [281 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Frank | Jul 1, 2008 17:40 | 134104 |
| ISLAMIC MARXIST LEFTIS ARE THE SAME ORGANIZATIONS [269 words] | TIRDAD GHARIB | Jul 3, 2008 14:40 | 134104 | ||
| ISLAMIST-LEFTIST ALLIED MENACE. FORMER PRESIDENT CARTER [619 words] | TIRDAD GHARIB | Jul 5, 2008 12:23 | 134104 | ||
| fascinating ! [33 words] | redmary | Nov 11, 2008 03:01 | 134104 | ||
| Alliance of Islam and the Left [237 words] | Frank | Jul 1, 2008 17:12 | 134098 | ||
| Excellent Survey of the Misguided Left's Irrational Embrace of Intolerant Islam [348 words] | GWK | Jul 1, 2008 16:21 | 134088 | ||
| Islamocommunism [299 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Lame Cherry | Jul 1, 2008 15:34 | 134086 | ||
| Islamocommunist is not a word! [278 words] | Nura | Jul 3, 2008 01:26 | 134086 | ||
| Islam and communism [278 words] | Straight_Talk_Luigi | Jul 4, 2008 14:49 | 134086 | ||
| Nura: Attagirl! You tell it like it (Islam) is! [241 words] | Plato | Jul 8, 2008 09:40 | 134086 | ||
| Teaching dear Nura that communism is also a religion [588 words] | dhimmi no more | Jul 10, 2008 06:54 | 134086 | ||
| Poisonous Stalin's anti-Zionist Marxism at radical left minority in Israel [688 words] | Edward | Dec 2, 2021 19:49 | 134086 | ||
| What role has political correctness in the West played in harbouring this alliance? [80 words] | Jaladhi | Jul 1, 2008 15:14 | 134084 | ||
| letter to Mr. Stockhausen [477 words] | Ynnatchkah | Jul 1, 2008 13:45 | 134076 | ||
| who designed who? [127 words] | mz ravin black | Jul 1, 2008 12:41 | 134073 | ||
| Leftists, Marxists and Islamists -- Strange bed-fellows! [71 words] | M.D'Souza | Jul 1, 2008 12:27 | 134071 | ||
| Not surprising at all [44 words] | Devasahayam | Jul 3, 2008 19:54 | 134071 | ||
| Islamist-leftist menance -- the enemy within [236 words] | sushil | Jul 1, 2008 12:24 | 134070 | ||
| West's Folly [299 words] | Jaladhi | Jul 2, 2008 09:53 | 134070 | ||
| Interesting and useful article [171 words] | Leonid Kaplun-Leonov | Jul 1, 2008 10:56 | 134067 | ||
| Valid, though late to print [6 words] | Devasahayam | Jul 1, 2008 10:43 | 134064 | ||
| All of this could have been avoided [237 words] | Rick | Jul 1, 2008 10:22 | 134059 | ||
| Rick, here is why Ayatolla was never assassinated in France to save lives [177 words] | Edward | Jul 9, 2008 03:21 | 134059 | ||
| Edward, you need to learn the difference bewteen apples and oranges [563 words] | rick | Jul 9, 2008 17:26 | 134059 | ||
| On the matter of apples and oranges [578 words] | Edward | Jul 11, 2008 02:01 | 134059 | ||
| Bush is an idealist with a sense of history (even though I think he's wrong) and you are an idealist with no sense of anything. [697 words] | Rick | Jul 11, 2008 17:43 | 134059 | ||
| dont spread democracy forcefully [297 words] | Edward | Jul 14, 2008 01:55 | 134059 | ||
| Edward you just don't get it and I am convinced you never will [673 words] | Rick | Jul 15, 2008 09:51 | 134059 | ||
| Rick, think more [459 words] | Edward | Jul 22, 2008 01:51 | 134059 | ||
| On Islam [13 words] | Dennis Middlebrooks | Jul 1, 2008 09:06 | 134050 | ||
| Apologies are in order :) [17 words] | Paul R. | Jul 5, 2008 08:04 | 134050 | ||
| The Red-Green Alliance [192 words] | Dr. Richard L. Benkin | Jul 1, 2008 08:59 | 134049 | ||
| RE: [The Islamist-Leftist] Allied Menace [33 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Xavier | Jul 1, 2008 08:35 | 134045 | ||
| Why [11 words] | joe | Aug 20, 2008 14:20 | 134045 | ||
| The leftists and Muslim vote bank in India [100 words] | Ramana Rajgopaul | Jul 1, 2008 06:37 | 134034 | ||
| Left Muslim alliance [129 words] | Thiagan | Jul 2, 2008 01:27 | 134034 | ||
| Islam, neo-cons and atheism [176 words] | G.Vishvas | Jul 1, 2008 06:04 | 134030 | ||
| "no it doesn't" [290 words] | Lactantius Jr | Jul 1, 2008 05:30 | 134026 | ||
| i'll just add alittle here [178 words] | mz ravin black | Jul 1, 2008 17:38 | 134026 | ||
| Allahu Akbar [121 words] | dihmmi no more | Jul 3, 2008 06:57 | 134026 | ||
| "what a noxious chant it is" [84 words] | Lactantius Jr | Jul 3, 2008 18:16 | 134026 | ||
| Samer is not an Arab. He is a Pakistani [411 words] | dhimmi no more | Jul 4, 2008 07:03 | 134026 | ||
| real arguments [115 words] | mz ravin black | Jul 4, 2008 15:45 | 134026 | ||
| Interesting information about allahu akbar [143 words] | dhimmi no more | Jul 5, 2008 12:59 | 134026 | ||
| "hey I'm impressed" [45 words] | Lactantius Jr | Jul 7, 2008 18:03 | 134026 | ||
| Islam plagiarizes hebrew [218 words] | yuval brandstetter | Jul 10, 2008 03:19 | 134026 | ||
| good point [242 words] | mz ravin black | Jul 10, 2008 22:48 | 134026 | ||
| Islam and its origin [599 words] | dhimmi no more | Jul 11, 2008 07:16 | 134026 | ||
| There are more Syriac than Hebrew loan words in the Qur'an [347 words] | dhimmi no more | Jul 11, 2008 07:32 | 134026 | ||
 dhimmi: Letter to Julanda brothers fact or fiction? [91 words] | Plato | Jul 12, 2008 01:21 | 134026 | ||
| Islam and its origin [388 words] | dhimmi no more | Jul 12, 2008 19:31 | 134026 | ||
| An addendum [81 words] | dhimmi no more | Jul 13, 2008 06:46 | 134026 | ||
| Something Foul [140 words] | Amin Riaz | Nov 7, 2012 13:04 | 134026 | ||
| Ken Livingstone, ex-Mayor of London [8 words] | John Hutchings | Jul 1, 2008 05:06 | 134023 | ||
| Ken Livingstone, ex-Mayor of London [19 words] | Georges | Jul 4, 2008 17:42 | 134023 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)