For Mustapha (Rabna Musahil 'Alayhu) conspiracy theory and the 9/11 atrocity!

Submitted by dhimmi no more (United States), Aug 6, 2006 at 07:51

My dear Mustapha (RMA) You wrote: "I don't believe that Muslims have hand in sept. 11" and I'm sure thousands of your pakistani bro (sic) will agree with you.

Then you wrote as evidence to support your bizarre assertion the following:

1. The Osama interview in the Daily Ummat (sic) I never understand why do Pakistanis mangle the Arabic language. So my questions to you my dear Mustapha are:

A. What makes you believe that the above interview took place? Pakistanis can be liars sometimes ...but I guess everyone else can be a liar.

B. As far as I know Usama does not speak Urdu, and almost all pakistanis are illiterate in Arabic, so I'm curious to know in which language did the reporter from the Daily Ummat (sic) conduct such interveiw? Arabic? Urdu? or English? And your answer is?

C. And what makes you believe that the reporter was not transmitting his own tendentious ideas about Islam being the religion of peace and all that blah blah blah and in the process publishing nonsense?

D. Even if such intereview has taken place why would you believe Usama's claim?

E. We here in the land of the infidels or kuffar are taught to be skeptics and look for evidence and contradictions both internal as well as external to the text. In this case there is no reason for you or for me to believe Usama more so when we see him chatting in an Arabic language (a language that you do not speak and neither would the reporter form the Daily Ummat (sic)) video wiht some radical sheik and informing him about his knowledge and participation in the plans of the 9/11 atrocity. Which source should we belive my dear Mustapha (RMA)?

So far your evidence is no evidence.

2. Abdul aziz Alomari (sic) did you mean: 3Abd al-3Aziz al-3Umari? If so what does this prove? let me help you: Nothing.

If this is your evidence I'm afraid to tell you that I do not believe you

You defend a diin (which means religion and not as pakistanis that know no Arabic claim that the word diin means: way of life/cultre) the al-diin al-Islami that brutalized your ancestors. Shame.

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".