| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
I agree with the professors
Reader comment on item: From the Halls of Academia
Submitted by Sam Sukkar (United States), Dec 28, 2002 at 20:03
I agree with the professors. This notion that any dissent in this country not be tolerated is ludicrous-- political debate and freedom to express one's views is the foundation on which this country was built. ..Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (124) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Racist Muslim gets fired [166 words] | Prashant | Nov 2, 2022 09:48 | 288164 | |
| 1 | 5 years later [86 words] | Jim Labbe | Jul 30, 2007 02:48 | 105109 | |
 Liberals and "PC" are our greatest threat [290 words] | Bruce | Sep 29, 2007 04:05 | 105109 | ||
| 1 | Wonder if they've read... [94 words] | MJA | Apr 18, 2005 21:04 | 21716 | |
| The problem of pluralism [90 words] | timpaul | May 6, 2003 04:49 | 8876 | ||
| 1 | Missing the point [262 words] | Baruch Lawrence | Apr 30, 2003 22:20 | 8810 | |
| Intellectual facism [382 words] | Justin Spigelman | Jan 27, 2003 01:57 | 6004 | ||
| Mixed priorities [583 words] | Don Canham | Jan 27, 2003 00:30 | 6003 | ||
| Disappointed at the quality of Professors' statement.. [76 words] | N. Sriram | Jan 13, 2003 10:11 | 5694 | ||
| Maybe the Prof's are more objective than many in their nation [286 words] | Matt Pack | Jan 13, 2003 02:06 | 5688 | ||
| Free speech, dissent, diversity: yes -- hypocrisy: no [166 words] | Steven Malcolm Anderson | Jan 10, 2003 00:04 | 5632 | ||
| Stan at SFSU -- Please contact me [31 words] | Stan Brin | Jan 8, 2003 21:06 | 5606 | ||
| The Left's Campus Tyrants [378 words] | Paul broughton | Jan 7, 2003 17:04 | 5567 | ||
| The Pot Calling the Kettle Black? [177 words] | Douglas Ball | Jan 7, 2003 16:57 | 5566 | ||
| No loyalty oaths, please [170 words] | Marian Hennings | Jan 7, 2003 11:45 | 5541 | ||
| Hah! [128 words] | scott howard | Jan 7, 2003 11:42 | 5540 | ||
| Enough already [53 words] | Carrolyn White | Jan 6, 2003 08:28 | 5515 | ||
| campus role in the 60's was different [102 words] | H Brown | Jan 5, 2003 12:16 | 5499 | ||
| The right to dissent [88 words] | Louis Wheeler | Jan 4, 2003 05:54 | 5476 | ||
| The Sedition Act [1000 words] | Darryl | Jan 3, 2003 14:56 | 5456 | |
| Colors. [153 words] | Frankie Lee | Jan 3, 2003 10:14 | 5449 | ||
| The refutation that didn't refute [36 words] | James K. Condon, MD | Jan 3, 2003 06:39 | 5446 | ||
| Dissenting academics [32 words] | S.C.Panda | Jan 2, 2003 04:20 | 5406 | ||
| Basic Human Rights of the Repressed [296 words] | Jim Rivard | Jan 1, 2003 22:24 | 5399 | ||
| Orwell lives on the American Campus - SF State Uber Alles [226 words] | Stan | Jan 1, 2003 18:25 | 5392 | ||
| 1 | University Profs still don't "get it" [236 words] | Alan Skorski | Jan 1, 2003 17:40 | 5389 | |
| Cowards [72 words] | James Glennon | Jan 1, 2003 12:17 | 5377 | ||
| Those who hate America [118 words] | Michael Braun | Jan 1, 2003 11:03 | 5376 | ||
| Right to Dissent? or Fomenting Dissent? [117 words] | Rick Lasure | Jan 1, 2003 09:51 | 5373 | ||
| Response to "A Fight for Freedom of Speech" [134 words] | Eric Kammer | Jan 1, 2003 01:31 | 5366 | ||
| Pick the War that Does Not Fit! [133 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Marj Lewis | Jan 1, 2003 01:21 | 5365 | ||
| Keep the Heat On! [160 words] | Tova Mattero | Dec 31, 2002 21:37 | 5362 | ||
| moral subjectivists [377 words] | Joseph Grossman | Dec 31, 2002 19:21 | 5358 | ||
| Reclaim Campuses! [60 words] | John Kunnari | Dec 31, 2002 17:48 | 5350 | ||
| 1 | Should Foner and Gilmore be fired? [227 words] | Stephen Walton | Dec 31, 2002 15:12 | 5343 | |
| Lack of Character [368 words] | R.D.J. | Dec 31, 2002 11:21 | 5323 | ||
| The Religious Right [467 words] | Arlinda DeAngelis | Dec 31, 2002 09:36 | 5318 | ||
| So now the enemy is us? [30 words] | Betty Furey | Dec 31, 2002 00:01 | 5316 | ||
| Where do these people come from? [203 words] | Charles Brown | Dec 30, 2002 22:53 | 5315 | ||
| 1 | Who pays the salaries of most professors? [136 words] | Alex Uan-Zo-li | Dec 30, 2002 22:52 | 5314 | |
| America and the "professors." [69 words] | Barbara Barron | Dec 30, 2002 22:39 | 5312 | ||
| They still hate us [27 words] | Gary Miller | Dec 30, 2002 22:39 | 5311 | ||
| How to clean up the mess? [261 words] | John Lindsay | Dec 30, 2002 16:43 | 5306 | ||
| I'll 'hazard' some answers :) [646 words] | F.H.Vondell Jr. | Dec 30, 2002 16:16 | 5304 | ||
| Dissension and Patriotism [147 words] | Raymond Low | Dec 30, 2002 13:38 | 5302 | ||
| Academic Dishonesty [151 words] | Lily Downing | Dec 30, 2002 10:54 | 5299 | ||
| Pernicious thought control assaults [117 words] | Dave Marciniak | Dec 30, 2002 09:23 | 5297 | ||
| When the US is attacked and at war [109 words] | Norman Wand | Dec 29, 2002 23:49 | 5294 | ||
| Timidity of the Campus Lions [276 words] | Mike McGlothlin | Dec 29, 2002 19:05 | 5292 | ||
| Foner and Gilmore's reply [215 words] | Ken Shillito | Dec 29, 2002 16:20 | 5289 | ||
| Same old BS [227 words] | Robert Vaughn | Dec 29, 2002 14:02 | 5287 | ||
| Right on [57 words] | Y. Milstein | Dec 29, 2002 12:31 | 5286 | ||
| Pipes has courageously critisized the 'high moral ground' held by Universities [171 words] | Jagan Mohan | Dec 29, 2002 12:23 | 5285 | ||
| Right of dissent [136 words] | miriam sherman | Dec 29, 2002 09:33 | 5281 | ||
| campus wits need watching [107 words] | Terijo | Dec 29, 2002 09:23 | 5280 | ||
| university students [596 words] | miriam sherman | Dec 29, 2002 09:20 | 5279 | ||
| War of Ideas on Campus [84 words] | Dr. Stephen Rittenberg | Dec 29, 2002 08:31 | 5278 | ||
| a responce to liberal professors [193 words] | robert singer | Dec 29, 2002 05:58 | 5276 | ||
| I disagree [90 words] | Andy | Dec 29, 2002 02:49 | 5271 | ||
| Justification of war with Iraq [75 words] | Allan Unger | Dec 29, 2002 00:36 | 5269 | ||
| PROFESSORS AGAINST AMERICA [62 words] | ROSE KELLY | Dec 28, 2002 23:40 | 5268 | ||
| The pain of dissent [190 words] | Mark Strassburg | Dec 28, 2002 23:17 | 5266 | ||
 I agree with the professors [36 words] | Sam Sukkar | Dec 28, 2002 20:03 | 5264 | ||
| Thank you, Daniel Pipes, for your courage [115 words] | Lila Imas | Dec 28, 2002 19:54 | 5262 | ||
| Professors who hate America ... [161 words] | Louisa B. McIntire-Brooks | Dec 28, 2002 19:30 | 5259 | ||
| Halls of Academia [350 words] | Arlinda DeAngelis | Dec 28, 2002 18:18 | 5257 | ||
| Dissent doesn't mean lack of patriotism - well, that depends [570 words] | Jerome D. Bashinski | Dec 28, 2002 17:55 | 5256 | ||
| Why squelch? [121 words] | Dick Baker | Dec 28, 2002 17:43 | 5255 | ||
| Re: #289bis: Pipes in LAT debates two anti-US profs [259 words] | Helen Selzer | Dec 28, 2002 17:28 | 5254 | ||
| They don't get it [41 words] | Arthur Kitay | Dec 28, 2002 17:10 | 5252 | ||
| Evasion as Usual [144 words] | Neil Abramson | Dec 28, 2002 16:54 | 5251 | ||
| Pipes' Legitimate Criticism [287 words] | Gabriel Grosso | Dec 28, 2002 16:53 | 5250 | |
| Skirting the truth [43 words] | Sruffine | Dec 28, 2002 16:50 | 5249 | ||
| In Hoc Signo Vinces [325 words] | CyberData | Dec 28, 2002 16:49 | 5248 | ||
| The Academic View of Freedom of Speech [184 words] | Ted Jonas | Dec 28, 2002 16:44 | 5247 | ||
| Campuses must reclaim lost ideological ground [244 words] | Sheila Ruffine | Dec 28, 2002 16:21 | 5246 | ||
| Outrage [411 words] | Alan Mencher | Dec 28, 2002 16:17 | 5245 | ||
| Thank you for your lens of reason! [345 words] | Satyam Bendapudi | Dec 28, 2002 16:10 | 5244 | |
| Foner and Gilmore [165 words] | Ben Creech | Dec 28, 2002 15:59 | 5243 | ||
| Daniel - again you are spot ON... [115 words] | KevinW | Dec 28, 2002 15:56 | 5241 | ||
| Glenda & Eric Can't Read.... [67 words] | Jim Anthony | Dec 28, 2002 15:47 | 5240 | ||
| My first disagreement with Pipes [75 words] | Eric Zornberg | Dec 28, 2002 15:30 | 5239 | ||
| Before the 1960's? [112 words] | Wes Kurtz | Dec 28, 2002 15:28 | 5238 | ||
| Cheers, your essay; Jeers, their non-response [206 words] | David J Crook | Dec 28, 2002 15:26 | 5237 | ||
| Trusting the Religious Right and Liberal Academia [78 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Linda Cooper | Dec 28, 2002 15:12 | 5236 | ||
| A right for Freedom of Speech [233 words] | Leslie Satenstein, Montreal Canada | Dec 28, 2002 14:59 | 5233 | ||
| Evasive Response [132 words] | Les Livingstone | Dec 28, 2002 14:46 | 5232 | ||
| Reply from two professors [61 words] | M Borg | Dec 28, 2002 14:45 | 5231 | ||
| The Academics are right [95 words] | Jim Gerlach | Dec 28, 2002 14:23 | 5230 | ||
| Thank Goodness for Academia [392 words] | Carl Masonberg | Dec 28, 2002 12:57 | 5228 | ||
| The right to protest [474 words] | James King | Dec 28, 2002 10:46 | 5224 | ||
| Force a University Decision [77 words] | Dr. Stuart A. Marcus | Dec 28, 2002 09:57 | 5221 | ||
| wayward academy? [149 words] | STEVE SAAF | Dec 28, 2002 09:53 | 5220 | ||
| OUR UNIVERSITIES [10 words] | DAROLD CHAMPAIGN | Dec 28, 2002 09:24 | 5219 | ||
| re:Art #988 [40 words] | Dixon Porter | Dec 28, 2002 08:28 | 5217 | ||
| An example [251 words] | Arun Gupta | Dec 28, 2002 07:10 | 5215 | ||
| Eternal apologists [66 words] | Jess Webb | Dec 28, 2002 06:09 | 5214 | ||
| University profs [182 words] | Irma Rochlin | Dec 28, 2002 03:22 | 5213 | ||
| Professors & Responsibility [782 words] | RM Paine | Dec 28, 2002 00:34 | 5210 | ||
| Quo Vadis, academia? [31 words] | A.M.Berlin | Dec 28, 2002 00:05 | 5208 | ||
| Ayn Rand made the same analysis in the late 60's [185 words] | Fred Rabeman | Dec 27, 2002 23:52 | 5207 | ||
| Can't we all just get along? [324 words] | Bob Desmond | Dec 27, 2002 23:25 | 5205 | ||
| University atrocities [334 words] | Lee Stewart | Dec 27, 2002 22:06 | 5203 | |
| Agreement [99 words] | Jack C. Whites, MD | Dec 27, 2002 21:51 | 5202 | ||
| please explain [34 words] | ruthie shleifer | Dec 27, 2002 21:12 | 5200 | ||
| How Do We do It? [103 words] | david l. thomson | Dec 27, 2002 20:38 | 5198 | ||
| True, but what does 'take back' mean? [98 words] | lewis goodkin | Dec 27, 2002 19:42 | 5197 | ||
| On Academia's Decline [229 words] | David Romero | Dec 27, 2002 19:33 | 5194 | ||
| 1 | Academia and young people [334 words] | Diana Nielsen | Dec 27, 2002 18:52 | 5192 | |
| Campus Backlash [137 words] | Moshe London | Dec 27, 2002 18:27 | 5191 | ||
| Academia [9 words] | Paul Goodrich | Dec 27, 2002 17:57 | 5188 | ||
| What universities have become [50 words] | Daniel Stevelman | Dec 27, 2002 17:39 | 5187 | ||
| Aren't students likely to believe just the reverse of what the Profs say ? [28 words] | Saul Pfeffer | Dec 27, 2002 17:26 | 5185 | ||
| Questionable assumption? [173 words] | Boris Frenkel | Dec 27, 2002 17:22 | 5184 | ||
| Europe and America [259 words] | Gabriel Grosso | Dec 27, 2002 17:01 | 5182 | ||
| We must all stand up for the truth! [240 words] | Rhonda Laikin | Dec 27, 2002 16:53 | 5181 | ||
| American Universities [48 words] | Jerrold Katz | Dec 27, 2002 16:02 | 5177 | ||
| Same pattern in Europe [80 words] | Cees de Rijk | Dec 27, 2002 15:42 | 5176 | ||
| What's our plan of action? [136 words] | Richard Burd | Dec 27, 2002 15:36 | 5175 | ||
| Can you Homeschool for College? [100 words] | jeff bukantz | Dec 27, 2002 15:18 | 5174 | ||
| High School with Ashtrays [349 words] | Jack Ajzenberg | Dec 27, 2002 15:18 | 5173 | ||
| Blah [9 words] | Charlie Jones | Mar 17, 2017 16:23 | 5173 | ||
| From the Halls of Academia [162 words] | Tony Padua | Dec 27, 2002 12:14 | 5166 | ||
| Freedom [64 words] | Gabriel Grosso | Dec 27, 2002 11:14 | 5164 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)