dhimmi plato, plato wasn't dhimmi

Submitted by susan (Italy), Jan 29, 2007 at 18:25

"Noah, I thought you knew your history. They have been fighting for 1400 years in their own backyards and there are still 1.2 billion of them or 2 billion if their claim is to be believed and growing."

that was our mistake, cut off all medical aid, nature will do the rest, there is simply not enough resources in those lands for that number.

So what do you suggest? pray for dhimmitude?

"Very relevant. You brought in the topic un-Americanism (shades of MaCarthy?). If you can invade America and reform (obliterate) the Red Indians why should the Muslims not believe that they can launch a migratory attack and reform (convert) the presents owners of that land mass."

let's suppose for a second that USA is illegaly occupied and australia too, what about europe? it consists of native europeans yet the muslims are willing to loot it too. your analogy fails miserabily. Oh and add south east asia where muslims don't belong, and china.

"What if the surviving Red Indians demand the new occupants go back to where they came from a la your demand that the Muslims go back to Arabia or wherever. "

is your kumbaya group telling you that the muslims are natives of america and europe? well newsflash for you, they are not.

the only land they can claim as theirs, although taken with bloodshed, lies and deception is the arabian peninsula.

"I believe you are not responsible for your father's crimes."

so the crimes of the muslims are by their "fathers"? I believe more of the children.

"Your ancestors were very un-American in the way they went about decimating populations in the Americas, Australia and New Zealand. "

still failing to address the hunger muslims have to get back sicily and spain... still wasting time talking about americas

"The Bible, which you don't believe in and which your ancestors were great believers in and most probably referred to when they went about scalping, if you examine its old parts, has enough to curl your toes, like dashing out babies brains (Deuteronomy?)."

the bible is written by men by inspiration of god, very different to have a book that's the exact word of the moon god. The bible no matter how many fake examples you have, was never meant to be taken literally.

That passage is often taken .... Yet the problems of today are not caused by christians.

Anyway, plato, if you dislike western civilization, usa's past or christianity you are free to leave. I bet USA gave you anyway a wealthy life and good income to be able to live anywhere else you want.

"Like the Muslim context trick the Christians have managed to explain all those nasty passages away by some absolutely amazing logic, which is all to the good. Now the Muslim texts claim direct descent (or is the same as the real original the Koran claims) from your ancestors' scriptures. Why can't you accept that there is a chance that Muslims of the future can also turn around and look at their ancestors beliefs with bemusement if not amusement."

because for this little detail you fail to note, one book is written by man, inspired by god, the other is the exact word of god. There is no reformation on the second....

"But let me recall a little incident that happened in India quite recently. A Muslim girl was raped by her father-in-law. The ulema went into a huddle and consulted each other and their scriptures and came up with a ruling that had all of India rocking. The girl was now the lawfully wedded wife of the rapist! Muslims in India were aghast. Religion can befuddle you but stuff like that become wake-up calls for even the most befuddled. Fundamentalism carried to the extreme is self-defeating. That is what is happening in the Muslim world. Unless stupidity is a disease peculiar to only those who were, are or become Muslim."

the sound of muslim protesting around the world is deafening. I might lose one ear.

"And the Muslims don't just believe they are blessed by god but are his chosen people."

and dhimmis like yourself are there to remind them of this

"Thank you Noah, Susan we need you. "

why? dhimmitude is such a good place.

But remember that me and noah would gladly do less than people like you. What can I do? I cannot stand dhimmies.

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".