69 million page views

To Fred Schlomka: Your "Middle Eastern" Construct is clear. Forgive me if "I pass."

Reader comment on item: My Testimony before the House Subcommittee on Israeli-Palestinian Negotiations
in response to reader comment: some comments for Mariana

Submitted by mariana (United States), Apr 4, 2007 at 17:03

mariana 4/4/07
To Fred Schlomka: Your "Middle Eastern" Construct is clear. Forgive me if "I pass."

Mr. Fred: Thank you for your offer to "google you;" I will graciously decline, preferring this particular, comfortable venue. We have gotten far afield of Daniel's Testimony on Israel-Palestine relations; but, maybe not. If the number of Israeli's feeling as you do is significant, then Israel is lost, and those Kadima morons ruining Israel might as well close up shop and start giving out plane tickets to Israel's modern Jews, so they can emigrate to some other modern, 1st world, democratic, Hi-Tech, 21st Century society.

Now that I understand, clearly, what you mean by "being Middle Eastern," it seems to me that you DO believe that you are "a special Jew" and that you will, some where down the line, be "treated differently" by the lunatic mobs lusting for Israel [if the "Palestinian Arabs" or "Israeli Arabs" also, from the sound of their proposed "Constitution"] were permitted to do so.

Your reference to the "Crusades" I will not discuss here at all, because clearly, your use of the word "Crusades," was meant to deliberately inflame, and I'm not interested in playing that game.

Your characterization of life in America is amazingly twisted; as probably, is your PollyAnna view of the results your Rise and World take-over by "Middle Eastern Values," would accomplish. You've maligned, mis-characterized and scorned all of Western Civilization and the Enlightenment one way or another, craving the "Civilization" centuries before even the Italian Renaissance. Sounds about like the kind of "civilization" the UN Overlords administered, any place they go.

That your Joys of Utopian Life under a[n Enlightened?] Caliphate refers, at best to a very tiny Elite consisting of less than 5% of the Worlds population at the time [of course, you'll be part of that 5%], with most humans held as "subjects," tenant farmers or in serfdom at best, is also amazing. Or will these benign Muslims run the game differently this time? Yes, you have to use the words Muslim/Islam [not just Middle Eastern] because Muslims constitute 220 Millions, and many of them live under Sharia. How many Hundreds of Thousands of the 220 Million Arab Muslims in the Middle East live well today under "Enlightened Middle Easterners??" Or is it just a few Tens of Thousands? And how many manage to eek out a meagre existence, at best, under the fiat of tyrannical princes or thugs? And how to you see the NEW CALIPHATE operating?

That your criticism of America required you to go back to the Slavery practiced during American Revolutionary and Civil Wars [without mentioning either that Slavery was practiced worldwide at that time or that the Civil War - under Republican American President Abraham Lincoln - was fought mid 19th Century, largely to end the SLAVERY which bothered you so much in America], is also interesting. A lot of white American boys [including Jews] fought and lost their lives and limbs in that war. The SLAVERY going on TODAY, all over the Middle East you've idealized and all over Muslim parts of Africa and Asia, apparently, BOTHERS YOU NOT AT ALL!

If that EastCoast US City you lived in was NY, it was certainly before NYC Republican Mayor Rudi Giuliani battled the inbred Lib/Democrat entrenched city government, police, schools, and mentality, and made the "welfare city" into a desirable place to live [also helped by 22 tax cuts during those 8 years]. Enforcing Laws, putting dangerous, anti-social animals in jail or killing them works "on the E. Coast of the US;" just as IDF, Mossad & Shin Bet make it work in one small corner of the Middle East.

Oh, Mr. Fred. It's a lovely dream world you live in: Just like the "1001 Arabian Nights" Sir Richard Burton chronicled. It's nice to create a Construct, label it, declare it's extant or will be, and then, not only insist it's where you live, but essentially foist it upon everyone else in your "Vision of the Future."

Whatever you're smoking, I'd like some. I have my own Construct that I'd like to move Everyone in the World into. This I guarantee. YOU and your children would have considerably more: personal Liberty, Freedom of Religion, Civil & Voting Rights, and Freedom of movement and action - in MY Construct, than I and mine would have in Yours. Ours is "One Nation, Under G*d," with Our Rights Descended to Each Individual from G*d and not from the State, Princes, Kings, Thugs or Caliphs.

We've reached an impasse. There is no point continuing because you are from Venus, and I am from Mars. Be well. mariana

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (79) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Former 'unreliable B'tselem propagandist' steps down from ratings giant Sustainalytics [569 words]Rita VAug 10, 2022 17:18284999
Another Pallywood fake B'tselem Basel Adra: Ma'on Farm [268 words]Diana from CaliforniaApr 15, 2022 12:02279811
Inviting people to use symmetry in reasoning [361 words]PrashantApr 16, 2022 16:39279811
Pallywood: more "Palestinian" cry for cameras only [Dec 2021] [187 words]Diana from CaliforniaApr 18, 2022 03:49279811
Assymetrical Posturing in Irrational Diatribes Rather Than Common Ground of Understanding Do Not Reconcile [76 words]M ToveyApr 18, 2022 18:55279811
"sustained and systematic effort to alter a bellicose mentality" [111 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
David BakinJun 5, 2007 15:0596116
Dr Pipes changing tone.. [112 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
HarrakApr 16, 2007 21:0189431
Thanks Dr Pipes [10 words]HarrakApr 17, 2007 21:2589431
Jaw-dropper [86 words]Mark RothApr 13, 2007 07:5489130
Martin Indyk and Dennis Ross are badly misinformed and a real danger to Israeli Jews [152 words]Kenneth BesigMar 18, 2007 02:4886685
Agree with Kenneth Besig's calibration re: Ross v Indyk; however... [597 words]marianaMar 19, 2007 22:2886685
Is It Time Yet? [367 words]Ron ThompsonMar 17, 2007 19:3986662
Hearings on Israeli-Palestinian "Progress" [23 words]Herb JuristMar 16, 2007 23:1086586
Pipes subcommittee comments [141 words]DeanMar 16, 2007 22:5286583
House subcommittee hearing [45 words]Steven LMar 16, 2007 17:2386543
Will this fairy tale never end? [187 words]DrRJPMar 5, 2007 18:0280412
Middle East Experts [152 words]DavodMar 12, 2007 05:0680412
Mysterious and Unique Logic? [184 words]Dean KitnickFeb 26, 2007 19:5479152
Re your position toward the Israeli-Palestinian conflict [68 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Gabriel RinzlerFeb 25, 2007 21:0278889
Let the Arabs rot... [304 words]Linda MooreFeb 26, 2007 12:1778889
"Let the Arabs Rot" by Linda [245 words]Fred SchlomkaFeb 28, 2007 11:1878889
OK, rot or prosper, I don't care which [194 words]Linda MooreFeb 28, 2007 17:4778889
Rot or Prosper continued [172 words]Fred SchlomkaMar 1, 2007 00:0878889
I find it hard to believe you are Israeli - all of your hostility is directed at Israel [310 words]Linda MooreMar 1, 2007 17:4478889
1There are many types of Israelis. We are no more homogenious than people in the USA [283 words]Fred SchlomkaMar 2, 2007 09:3578889
Litmus test is dangerous to Antisemites [66 words]DeMar 2, 2007 17:3378889
Visit this site... [143 words]Linda MooreMar 2, 2007 19:0578889
Of Maps and fatalities [454 words]Fred SchlomkaMar 4, 2007 05:1478889
To: Fred Schlomka, Incredible. "You just can't make it up!" [454 words]marianaMar 19, 2007 20:4178889
To Daniel and Gabriel: on "Winning" [522 words]marianaMar 20, 2007 00:4978889
to Mariana [100 words]ASMar 22, 2007 00:3878889
Fred Schlomka: -Israeli leftist- Is there a difference? [87 words]Mr. ShawarmaMar 27, 2007 23:4678889
Boorish title from Mr. Shawamra [192 words]Fred SchlomkaMar 29, 2007 04:1178889
To Mariana from an israeli [461 words]Fred SchlomkaMar 29, 2007 16:2678889
I applaud those whom you and Jonathan Cook refer to as "thugs" and yes, Jew hater = Ashkenazi Leftist [402 words]Mr.ShawarmaMar 29, 2007 17:0578889
attack by Shawamra [197 words]Fred SchlomkaMar 31, 2007 02:3078889
Fred Schlomka's comments [319 words]Mr. ShawarmaMar 31, 2007 17:3078889
To: Fred Schlomka: on "armchairs and nonsense." [1572 words]marianaApr 1, 2007 12:5078889
some comments for Mariana [878 words]Fred SchlomkaApr 2, 2007 04:3278889
To: AS: This is an ISLAM vs EVERYONE ELSE issue [943 words]marianaApr 2, 2007 11:3878889
To Fred Schlomka: Your "Middle Eastern" Construct is clear. Forgive me if "I pass." [776 words]marianaApr 4, 2007 17:0378889
Fred Schlomka - Hill Top Youth comments verified [40 words]Fred SchlomkaDec 3, 2008 03:4178889
B'TSELEM: Anti Israel liars, unreliable source, propagandists , posing as "human rights activists" [2927 words]FilipSep 1, 2020 11:5778889
Btselem: fake & hypocritical In face of publicized racist Arab attacks inside Israel [77 words]NazariasApr 19, 2021 06:5578889
Fake lying B'Tselem' / Haaretz Basel al-Adara reminds Jussie Smollet [712 words]BassemDec 3, 2021 16:4078889
Exposure of B'tselem's criminal Ezra Bawi and unreliable Haaretz's war on program that exposed him [2865 words]FilipDec 5, 2021 09:1978889
Radical bigot Zehava Galon lack of basic English exposed too [1877 words]FilipOct 18, 2022 19:2378889
WHICH PUBLICATIONS? [21 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Mike DavisFeb 25, 2007 20:2878883
War of Wills [455 words]OliverFeb 25, 2007 17:4778869
Negotiation is valuable, even if you believe it won't bring peace [277 words]Erik NelsonFeb 25, 2007 17:2378866
Illumination [297 words]Felipe OrnelasMar 1, 2007 18:4778866
Chamberlain negotiated at Munich... [149 words]DeanMar 16, 2007 23:2478866
Biological [126 words]Don HedemanFeb 25, 2007 17:0978865
ACTIONS HAVE CONSEQUENCES.. [186 words]DONVANMar 20, 2007 16:0178865
To Donvan: Interesting; would you expand. [152 words]marianaApr 2, 2007 11:5578865
It is not academic.. [174 words]DONVANApr 3, 2007 10:3278865
An unlikely negotiation [289 words]Melvyn RosensteinFeb 25, 2007 15:2978850
re "Arab & Muslim World." [160 words]Jascha KesslerFeb 25, 2007 15:2778849
history and the arab and islamic world [87 words]rodney allsworthFeb 25, 2007 22:3678849
Reaction to Pipes, Indyk, Makovsky Congressional Testimony [187 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Martin KaufmanFeb 25, 2007 10:0878790
The Good Old Gulag Days. [42 words]LeeFeb 25, 2007 09:3578788
Apology for not making it with my big Speed Graphic camera [233 words]Dan SchwartzFeb 25, 2007 08:4378780
Re House Subcommittee on Israeli -Palestinian Nego... [26 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
david levyFeb 25, 2007 06:2078766
consider this... [140 words]JoshuaFeb 22, 2007 00:0578292
RE: Great debate [279 words]Donald Grant CheesmanFeb 25, 2007 18:5778292
"OH NO!" "DON'T SAY IT!" But ... "BRAVO!" [1378 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Sofa SogoodFeb 21, 2007 16:5378222
Peace or Genocide [184 words]Felipe OrnelasFeb 20, 2007 12:1878061
Hate to disagree with you but I do. [105 words]PeterFeb 20, 2007 11:1278054
Hate to disagree with your disagreement, but I do [106 words]Dean KitnickFeb 20, 2007 18:2878054
No dean, you have misunderstood ... [128 words]PeterFeb 21, 2007 23:1178054
No misunderstanding, I just think you're wrong. [86 words]Dean KitnickFeb 22, 2007 20:0878054
I agree with Peter [51 words]Irish SavantFeb 25, 2007 07:1078054
Reality Check [219 words]LarryFeb 25, 2007 09:3878054
Some things are non-negotiable [106 words]ZerubbabelFeb 25, 2007 10:1778054
Actually you needn't wonder. My comments stand on their face. [166 words]PeterFeb 25, 2007 15:3078054
Furthermore [69 words]PeterFeb 25, 2007 15:3678054
The genocide gene evolves [258 words]AronFeb 25, 2007 19:0078054
Why elevate Israel legitimacy to a debate? [59 words]JakeFeb 26, 2007 11:4278054
Subcommittee Investigations [435 words]MichaelMar 3, 2007 12:5578054

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)