| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
The problem of Zionism
Reader comment on item: Zionism's Bleak Present
Submitted by Richard D. Wittrup (United States), Oct 11, 2007 at 19:20
The problem of any ethnically exclusive political idea such as Zionism is its lack of a theoretical foundation in political philosophy.
One sign of that is the absence of any clearly expressed concept that justifies why non-Jews in Israel should accept that they will be ruled by Jews or why leave if they don't want to be ruled by Jews.
Dislike
Submitting....
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (114) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| How far they go [229 words] | J. Stein | Nov 3, 2009 18:31 | 164017 | ||
| Burg praises pseudo-historical book by Shlomo Sand [112 words] | Jason | Nov 1, 2009 18:04 | 163937 | ||
| Zionism [65 words] | David Gueiros | Nov 7, 2007 15:10 | 113352 | ||
| Israel shares the same conundrum as the rest of the west. [584 words] | Homefront | Oct 22, 2007 20:54 | 112161 | ||
 There won't be an Islamic world government. [321 words] | Katey | Oct 26, 2007 15:04 | 112161 | ||
| I would never postulate an Islamic world government [168 words] | Homefront | Oct 27, 2007 05:11 | 112161 | ||
| Maybe not. [175 words] | Kattey | Oct 27, 2007 21:00 | 112161 | ||
| Let Arabs prove ancient existence in Israel. [298 words] | Kattey Wagar | Oct 22, 2007 12:53 | 112137 | ||
| Kattey don't bother [423 words] | Homefront | Oct 22, 2007 21:32 | 112137 | ||
| Another example of Islamic Historical revisionist nonsense [44 words] | Homefront | Oct 22, 2007 21:59 | 112137 | ||
| A Note of Thanks: Very Interesting [438 words] | Ynnatchkah | Oct 23, 2007 05:34 | 112137 | ||
| I agree -- Israel should fight the archaeology issue hard [132 words] | Charles Martel | Oct 23, 2007 12:52 | 112137 | ||
| Religious beliefs of Muslims. [392 words] | Kate Wagar | Oct 25, 2007 18:28 | 112137 | ||
| Delightful news indeed [46 words] | Ynnatchkah | Oct 26, 2007 01:10 | 112137 | ||
| MPD [206 words] | donvan | Oct 26, 2007 12:35 | 112137 | ||
| Israel's Sacrifice: Should Stop Right Away [179 words] | skmiller | Oct 19, 2007 11:14 | 111916 | ||
| Duty of Christians [106 words] | Phil Greend | Oct 18, 2007 22:40 | 111881 | ||
| The Islamic war on Christianity has been giong on for some time [37 words] | Dr RJP | Oct 22, 2007 12:35 | 111881 | ||
| 1 | Bush's "Two State Solution" [402 words] | Dr. Howard D. Garber | Oct 18, 2007 04:55 | 111775 | |
| Iraqi MP Iyad Jamal Al-Din Video Clips - Backwards Arabs Use Israel as a Pretext - Bless America - On Terrorism - On Secularism - On Democracy [918 words] | Sofa Sogood | Oct 17, 2007 19:26 | 111726 | ||
| a ray of hope - everyone should see this! [54 words] | jennifer solis | Oct 20, 2007 15:18 | 111726 | ||
| Good Idea - Requested Fox to Show the Clips -- Would Columbia U Have Invited and Given Him the World Stage for Free Speech? [78 words] | Sofa Sogood | Oct 21, 2007 10:41 | 111726 | ||
| I don't think so [71 words] | jennifer solis | Oct 24, 2007 14:51 | 111726 | ||
| Friends that will stick closer than a brother. [346 words] | Susan Browne | Oct 17, 2007 12:56 | 111698 | ||
| Friends that will stick closer than a brother [233 words] | Harvey London | Oct 18, 2007 13:27 | 111698 | ||
| We need your encouragement [349 words] | Susan Browne | Oct 19, 2007 11:19 | 111698 | ||
| Biblical Christianity and Israel [30 words] | Clifford ishii | Oct 16, 2007 20:05 | 111654 | ||
| israel defenceless [13 words] | skydiver | Oct 16, 2007 14:06 | 111611 | ||
| Israel will survive and Israelis have all the right to live in peace [139 words] | Egyptian Christian | Oct 15, 2007 12:59 | 111513 | ||
| ONLY SOLUTION TO PALI-ISRAELI CONFLICT [106 words] | Bruce Sterling | Oct 15, 2007 16:55 | 111513 | ||
| Bruce Sterling [349 words] | shayna | Oct 16, 2007 17:00 | 111513 | ||
| How the palestinians overcome their racism, cultural imperialism and religious intolerance. [87 words] | Egyptian Christian | Oct 18, 2007 10:53 | 111513 | ||
| DON'T DESPAIR [79 words] | Bruce Sterling | Oct 15, 2007 08:35 | 111504 | ||
| A modest proposal [134 words] | Bob | Oct 15, 2007 02:24 | 111497 | ||
| "MEDIA WAR AGAINST ISRAEL: FROM INVERSION OF THE TRUTH TO INVERSION OF REALITY" [1592 words] | Sofa Sogood | Oct 14, 2007 17:17 | 111475 | ||
| Don't worry about Israel, Dr Pipes ! [232 words] | Anne-Marie Delcambre | Oct 14, 2007 13:47 | 111458 | ||
| Not just Israel at risk [184 words] | lee bailey | Oct 14, 2007 11:12 | 111439 | ||
| Why all the fuss about Jewish nationalism ? [507 words] | Anne-Marie Delcambre | Oct 14, 2007 06:55 | 111427 | ||
| Dhimmitude [162 words] | yuval Brandstetter MD | Oct 16, 2007 01:32 | 111427 | ||
| Famous Oxford Union Debating Society - Hosting One-Sided "Death to Israel" Debate Starring David Irving, Holocaust Denier and Other Notorious Anti-Semites [184 words] | Sofa Sogood | Oct 13, 2007 20:49 | 111403 | ||
| Zionist responsibility [114 words] | Gene C. Sproul | Oct 13, 2007 18:10 | 111399 | ||
| Mr. Sproul: maybe your friend should be outraged at what Palestinians have been doing. [733 words] | Dr RJP | Oct 15, 2007 22:45 | 111399 | ||
| Inconvenient "truths" [392 words] | Gene C. Sproul | Oct 16, 2007 18:58 | 111399 | ||
| "Inconvenient lies? [739 words] | Dr RJP | Oct 18, 2007 14:32 | 111399 | ||
| Mr Sproul and the inconvenient truths [328 words] | Harvey | Oct 19, 2007 12:33 | 111399 | ||
| Palestinian Refugees and the "Right of Return [640 words] | Gene C. Sproul | Oct 19, 2007 18:23 | 111399 | ||
| Conservatives see Carter as a coo-coo, too. Want the real scoop? Read Joan Peters [405 words] | Dr RJP | Oct 21, 2007 00:58 | 111399 | ||
| Harvey: we're on the same page [388 words] | Dr RJP | Oct 22, 2007 12:31 | 111399 | ||
| "Jerusalem" is mentioned in the Koran....once [170 words] | jennifer solis | Oct 27, 2007 17:33 | 111399 | ||
| Thank you, Jennifer. Everything you said is true, except... [141 words] | Dr RJP | Oct 29, 2007 14:19 | 111399 | ||
| Thank you for the correction [140 words] | jennifer solis | Oct 29, 2007 19:45 | 111399 | ||
| There were NO palestinians in Israel and they're not even "Palestinians" [60 words] | marlene | Mar 14, 2008 04:47 | 111399 | ||
| Pallywood: the Lethal Weapon [798 words] | Noam | Dec 27, 2021 12:07 | 111399 | ||
| A solution [206 words] | Paul M. Neville | Oct 13, 2007 17:44 | 111397 | ||
| Add to the bleaker picture - US economy. [411 words] | Syed Kasim | Oct 12, 2007 17:09 | 111296 | ||
| syed [251 words] | shayna | Oct 13, 2007 18:30 | 111296 | ||
| Islamic tolerance? Really? [305 words] | dhimmi no more | Oct 14, 2007 10:55 | 111296 | ||
| Can you say Entrepreneur [735 words] | SS | Oct 16, 2007 02:19 | 111296 | ||
| Ayat a sayf and ayat al jzya [49 words] | Harry | Oct 23, 2007 11:59 | 111296 | ||
| Only solution rule of law, minority and women rights and West to sober up [236 words] | Mohamed Eljahmi | Oct 12, 2007 14:56 | 111275 | ||
| Postpartum Depression [130 words] | Gnarlodious | Oct 12, 2007 11:40 | 111258 | ||
| If Israelis don't wake up now, there will not be 2025 for them [72 words] | Benzion | Oct 12, 2007 08:52 | 111241 | ||
| Leading Israeli intellectuals sign petition calling for negotiations with Hamas [461 words] | Mladen Andrijasevic | Oct 12, 2007 03:24 | 111217 | ||
| Add to the bleaker picture - US economy. [254 words] | Syed Kasim | Oct 12, 2007 02:34 | 111215 | ||
| Live and let live [111 words] | Syed Kasim | Oct 12, 2007 01:56 | 111214 | ||
| Fight fire with fire: make "Islamic fascist" a household word. [448 words] | Dr RJP | Oct 12, 2007 01:22 | 111209 | ||
| ISRAEL IS A RECOGNIZED SOVEREIGN COUNTRY!!! [415 words] | jennifer solis | Oct 12, 2007 00:22 | 111206 | ||
| Alas, poor Zionism [102 words] | Bob Miller | Oct 11, 2007 23:52 | 111205 | ||
| our strenghs and weaknesses [51 words] | Dan, Australia | Oct 11, 2007 23:01 | 111202 | ||
| Zionism's Story a Wonderful Ending [359 words] | Infidel | Oct 11, 2007 22:42 | 111201 | ||
| like Kosovo [352 words] | obilic | Oct 11, 2007 21:54 | 111196 | ||
| obilic [468 words] | shayna | Oct 13, 2007 17:37 | 111196 | ||
 The problem of Zionism [60 words] | Richard D. Wittrup | Oct 11, 2007 19:20 | 111186 | ||
| Dutch lack of identity, unique Palestinian identity, and Zionism [182 words] | Joe Morgan | Oct 11, 2007 18:09 | 111177 | ||
| you may be surprised [498 words] | Yuval Brandstetter MD | Oct 11, 2007 17:06 | 111172 | ||
| Don't be such a downer [73 words] | Deborah Blumenthal | Oct 11, 2007 15:57 | 111163 | ||
| Deborah, dont just talk, do something [43 words] | yuval brandstetter MD | Oct 12, 2007 04:43 | 111163 | ||
| where Israel went wrong [148 words] | Irish Savant | Oct 11, 2007 15:26 | 111159 | ||
| regurgitate partisan platitudes much? [193 words] | bos | Oct 11, 2007 19:13 | 111159 | ||
| I do not agree. Where Israel really went wrong- When it Returned the Sinai to Rely on Big Daddy USA [232 words] | James Burke | Oct 12, 2007 06:43 | 111159 | ||
| in re Submitted by Irish Savant (United States), Oct 11, 2007 at 15:26 [243 words] | argawarga | Oct 12, 2007 09:35 | 111159 | ||
| Women who stand with Zionism [129 words] | Jeanene | Oct 11, 2007 15:04 | 111154 | ||
| Jeanene [427 words] | shayna | Oct 13, 2007 18:01 | 111154 | ||
| Zionism's Bleak Present [124 words] | Suren Sukhtankar | Oct 11, 2007 14:43 | 111153 | ||
| Wide acclaim? [108 words] | Syarikat | Oct 11, 2007 11:28 | 111135 | ||
| I'm afraid existential ennui isn't Israel's main problem [331 words] | Charles Martel | Oct 11, 2007 11:13 | 111134 | ||
| Defense of Zion [463 words] | M. Tovey | Oct 11, 2007 11:04 | 111133 | ||
| the tragedy of it all [476 words] | jennifer solis | Oct 12, 2007 16:40 | 111133 | ||
| Who gets the blame [54 words] | David W. Lincoln | Oct 11, 2007 10:51 | 111131 | ||
| Israel forever [298 words] | Rebecca Moulds | Oct 11, 2007 10:41 | 111129 | ||
| bless you [49 words] | marlene | Mar 14, 2008 04:30 | 111129 | ||
| Israel will survive [206 words] | SFC, Donald Grant Cheesman | Oct 11, 2007 09:43 | 111123 | ||
| Even more pessimism [53 words] | roslyn esther | Oct 11, 2007 08:55 | 111118 | ||
| I understand how you feel [611 words] | Ken Besig | Oct 11, 2007 08:45 | 111117 | ||
| Alarmed [114 words] | Atilla | Oct 11, 2007 05:37 | 111088 | ||
| National Identity [97 words] | Edward Halper | Oct 11, 2007 03:07 | 111081 | ||
| Zionism's Bleak Present [194 words] | Sharon | Oct 11, 2007 02:36 | 111080 | ||
| Our history should give you some hope! [382 words] | Gershon Seif | Oct 11, 2007 02:22 | 111079 | ||
| Evolution needed? [651 words] | Archimedes2 | Oct 11, 2007 01:37 | 111075 | ||
| disagree [250 words] | housam jarrar | Oct 11, 2007 01:28 | 111074 | ||
| Zionism's Bleak Future [135 words] | Talia Zentara | Oct 11, 2007 00:52 | 111071 | ||
| IS THIS OUR FATE? [525 words] | Geno M. | Oct 11, 2007 00:31 | 111070 | ||
| 3 | The lights are going out all over europe tonight [1658 words] | Antonia Gilligan | Jan 26, 2008 01:00 | 111070 | |
| If not now, when? [40 words] | Carl Sesar | Oct 11, 2007 00:25 | 111069 | ||
| If not now, when? [23 words] | SHD | Nov 19, 2009 23:58 | 111069 | ||
| bleak is as bleak does [304 words] | John W. McGinley | Oct 10, 2007 23:12 | 111059 | ||
| Liberalism [51 words] | Ynnatchkah | Oct 10, 2007 22:01 | 111050 | ||
| Lack of knowledge [79 words] | Lana Fayman | Oct 10, 2007 21:12 | 111042 | ||
| Zionism [139 words] | Donald W. Bales | Oct 10, 2007 21:06 | 111040 | ||
| ZIONISM BLEAK PRESENT [471 words] | JACQUES HADIDA | Oct 10, 2007 21:00 | 111039 | ||
| Not them too... [65 words] | Diana | Oct 10, 2007 20:30 | 111037 | ||
| ONLY SOLUTION: GAZA TO EGYPT; PARTS OF WEST BANK LINKED TO JORDAN [164 words] | G. Marcus | Oct 10, 2007 20:28 | 111035 | ||
| Agree with Marcus, but I'm afraid Arabs too smart for that [167 words] | Charles Martel | Oct 12, 2007 12:37 | 111035 | ||
| It's always darkest... [80 words] | LDC | Oct 10, 2007 20:25 | 111034 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)