To Mr Amith Parsotam

Submitted by Jurist Benedictos Mohamd Ali (Sweden), Mar 12, 2009 at 09:41

To Amith Parsotam

Thanks for your comment and your questions. I am going to answer you late but I would like to assert that its true that those who think that they are muslims are worshiping thier imams because 80% of what they practing is invinted by imams in the name of Allah and Mohamad. One oth e evdences is a question for you:

Muslims and thier imams claimed and claiming that Mohamad explained the Qur2an1 Now you know that many imams isussed and published Qur2an's Interprtation " TAFSIR ", such as tafisr al Qurtubi, Tafisr Alsha3rawi , Tafsier Ibn Kathir ...etc.... So my questions are:

1- would you tell me if Mohamd explained the Qur2an then why it dosent exist a tafsier which called " Tafsir Mohamd "!!!!!!

2- If Mohamd isussed a tafsir to qur2an , then why hte imams should isusse many tafsiers which even contradict each other!?

3- If the Sunna or Hadith concederd as a tafisser then why the iamas should explain it!!!?

4- If the Sunna is a tafser then why and until now no imams know the real meaning of many words and verse of the Qur2an!? Maybe they mean that Mohamd forgot to explain it!

Aske your imams where is tafsir Mohamdconcerning the begining of some suras means such as Mariam, Al3ankabot, Yasin?

Aske them where is tafiser Mohamad to " Al3aser"? Because they dont know exactly its meaning!

And more. You can send me your email if you would like to send you all about that . At the same time I promise you to answer your question

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".