| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
No, under UNHCR it would be different.
Reader comment on item: Count Palestine Refugees?
in response to reader comment: UN definition of refugee routinely extends to descendants if certain conditions are not met
Submitted by Tilman Tarach (Germany), Aug 4, 2015 at 17:41
There is indeed a difference between UNHCR and UNRWA definition of a refugee.
Take the palestinians in Jordan:
Around 2 Millions palestinians live in Jordan and have the Jordan citizenship + passport, but are still considered as refugees by UNRWA. These are 40% of all Palestinian refugees. And they would NOT be refugees under UNHCR eligibility rules.
Dislike
Submitting....
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
Reader comments (79) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Trump ended US funding to UNWRA [145 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Robert | Sep 3, 2018 08:36 | 244586 | |
 My apology for my imprecision! It's your doubt/Hesitation I complain about essentially, regarding US President Trump [597 words] | Robert | Sep 29, 2018 16:24 | 244586 | ||
| Fake Refugees? [70 words] | Victor Scott | Sep 2, 2018 17:13 | 244578 | ||
| 2 | But thanks to the nutty definition of "Palestinian", Jordan is a majority-Palestinian state [87 words] | Anon. | Jul 20, 2018 11:43 | 243820 | |
| 1 | Palestinians, fanatticism "Made in Islam" [75 words] | steven L | Oct 30, 2014 23:59 | 219052 | |
| Refugees [77 words] | Sandy | Aug 28, 2012 14:23 | 198235 | ||
| La propagande visant à délégitimer les droits du Peuple Juif sur Eretz Israël n'est pas nouvelle... [1036 words] | Mosche Ashkelon | Jul 12, 2012 23:10 | 197209 | ||
| 1 | Refugee status [77 words] | Stas | Jul 8, 2012 00:29 | 197062 | |
| 5 | What Every Free Lebanese Thinks [618 words] | Phoenician Lebanese | Jun 26, 2012 08:17 | 196706 | |
| 1 | descendants as refugees applicable to all? [47 words] | bernard ross | Jun 21, 2012 11:39 | 196499 | |
| 3 | Outrageous US taxpayer aid [49 words] | Charles | Jun 12, 2012 23:20 | 196284 | |
| 1 | The "fetid, dark heart"? [129 words] | Mellvin A. Fechter | Jun 9, 2012 12:52 | 196171 | |
| 4 | Obama administration fumbles [62 words] | stevias | Jun 7, 2012 14:46 | 196108 | |
| 2 | only half the problem [72 words] | peter legur | Jun 18, 2012 08:18 | 196108 | |
| 1 | Yes, but why is that our problem? [151 words] | stevias | Jun 18, 2012 17:37 | 196108 | |
| 4 | why is this so different than other historical resettling? [177 words] | stanley b | Jun 7, 2012 14:14 | 196105 | |
| You feed a stray cat regularly, it has a litter, you are not absolved of responsibility. [61 words] | peter legur | Jun 19, 2012 05:38 | 196105 | ||
| In defense of stray cats... [51 words] | Kepha | Sep 9, 2018 22:04 | 196105 | ||
| 3 | Refugees are not the main issue [136 words] | stanley b | Jun 7, 2012 14:07 | 196104 | |
| 4 | What is a real Palestinian [93 words] | sara | Jun 7, 2012 14:02 | 196103 | |
| 2 | Why are they singled out? [146 words] | Stas | Jun 6, 2012 17:26 | 196077 | |
| 3 | Count Palestinian Refugees...Its about Time. [106 words] | Anne | Jun 5, 2012 15:29 | 196052 | |
| 1 | 1948 happened, get over it! [140 words] | PacificOcean | Jun 4, 2012 21:34 | 196036 | |
| 4 | The UN and Boneheads [119 words] | Jay1 | Jun 2, 2012 10:50 | 195986 | |
| 9 | So-called Palestinians and their lies [1198 words] | Martin Horan | Jun 1, 2012 12:21 | 195971 | |
| Palestinian refugee is an icon of islamism unity to grow [237 words] | Angel | Jun 2, 2012 19:59 | 195971 | ||
| Muslims ... [108 words] | fuzzy1 | Jun 5, 2012 09:10 | 195971 | ||
| 6 | Islam and lying [1309 words] | Martin Horan | Jun 6, 2012 12:07 | 195971 | |
| 2 | Re: the so-called Palestinians [280 words] | DEBORAH THE JUDGE | Jun 7, 2012 10:34 | 195971 | |
| 1 | Hi Deborah. [744 words] | Martin Horan | Jun 7, 2012 19:00 | 195971 | |
| A late response for Martin [225 words] | DEBORAH THE JUDGE | Jun 21, 2012 23:48 | 195971 | ||
| Spot on again, Deborah. [453 words] | Martin Horan | Jun 23, 2012 12:08 | 195971 | ||
| 3 | Count Palestine Refugees? [127 words] | Judith | May 31, 2012 17:13 | 195950 | |
| 1 | Palestinian Refugees [1435 words] | Renee Bouvier | May 31, 2012 15:01 | 195946 | |
| 1 | Again... [345 words] | Peter Herz | May 31, 2012 05:37 | 195932 | |
| 3 | male descendants [71 words] | myth | May 31, 2012 04:25 | 195929 |
| 3 | Ludicrous [120 words] | sara | Jun 7, 2012 14:29 | 195929 | |
| 2 | the compassionate society [95 words] | myth | May 31, 2012 04:05 | 195928 | |
| 2 | For 64 years UNRWA got away with perparing generations of Arabs to be Jew killers [144 words] | NuritG | May 31, 2012 03:50 | 195927 | |
| 1 | Solution: No pay check [48 words] | Angel | Jun 4, 2012 18:32 | 195927 | |
| 1 | The USA, EU and UN are human rights and social justice abusers [74 words] | NuritG | Jun 5, 2012 01:50 | 195927 | |
| 4 | How I became a Palestinian refugee [26 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Peter | May 30, 2012 06:40 | 195911 | |
| Lucky man ! [157 words] | Jon, a Brit in Euroland | May 31, 2012 05:23 | 195911 | ||
| Remember this? [29 words] | Ugri | May 30, 2012 02:44 | 195903 | ||
| 3 | How to solve the problem? [145 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | John Philips | May 30, 2012 00:23 | 195902 | |
| 2 | Oxymoron of Arab unity???? [36 words] | Moshe | May 31, 2012 08:24 | 195902 | |
| Then isn't two states the logical solution [50 words] | John Philips | Jun 2, 2012 02:43 | 195902 | ||
| causes of anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism [156 words] | John Philips | Jun 4, 2012 04:46 | 195902 | ||
| 2 | Two state, one state keep bombing the other? [23 words] | Angel | Jun 4, 2012 19:36 | 195902 | |
| Another possible solution [85 words] | John Philips | Jun 5, 2012 07:00 | 195902 | ||
| 2 | Re: John Phillip, "Another possibility?" [67 words] | Angel | Jun 8, 2012 02:44 | 195902 | |
| Two states will NOT work [88 words] | Stormy | Jun 10, 2012 22:05 | 195902 | ||
| 1 | Like we need more terrorists in America [66 words] | Stormy | Jun 10, 2012 22:13 | 195902 | |
| Jerusalem should be a city of peace [64 words] | John Philipss | Jun 13, 2012 01:14 | 195902 | ||
| Palestinians in America [166 words] | John Philips | Jun 13, 2012 01:25 | 195902 | ||
| 2 | A Huge Opportunity [199 words] | Liz | May 29, 2012 22:37 | 195900 | |
| 1 | UN definition of refugee routinely extends to descendants if certain conditions are not met [286 words] | Esther Riley | May 29, 2012 16:35 | 195896 | |
 No, under UNHCR it would be different. [57 words] | Tilman Tarach | Aug 4, 2015 17:41 | 195896 | ||
| To be a refugee or to not be a refugee; that is the question [76 words] | Rebecca | May 29, 2012 14:38 | 195895 | ||
| 1 | Proliferation of Liberated Palestinian Refugees [152 words] | George Haas | May 29, 2012 12:27 | 195894 | |
| 2 | A time bomb aimed at the heart of Israel [25 words] | Moshe | May 29, 2012 12:17 | 195893 | |
| within the definition of racism [23 words] | myth | May 31, 2012 06:44 | 195893 | ||
| Moshe, I stand with Israel [241 words] | Stormy | Jun 10, 2012 22:40 | 195893 | ||
| Help me understand [78 words] | Ibn Ismail | Jun 12, 2012 15:20 | 195893 | ||
| Almighty Eternal Sovereign to Give Israel a New Heart-Ezekiel 36:26-28 [372 words] | M. Tovey | Jun 12, 2012 16:37 | 195893 | ||
| 3 | why? [138 words] | the Grand Infidel of Kaffiristan | Jun 13, 2012 08:54 | 195893 | |
| 1 | An Answer to Help Understand the Judeo-Christianity Connection [333 words] | M. Tovey | Jun 14, 2012 19:25 | 195893 | |
| 1 | Time to Clean Out the State Department [54 words] | Dave | May 29, 2012 12:07 | 195892 | |
| 1 | America MUST stand by Israel [56 words] | Stormy | Jun 10, 2012 22:44 | 195892 | |
| 5 | The Glorious British Mandate for Palestine. [64 words] | Jon, a Brit in Euroland | May 29, 2012 11:07 | 195891 | |
| 1 | this is depressing [323 words] | john w mcginley | May 29, 2012 10:45 | 195890 | |
| World refugee camp avoided through sharia implementation [152 words] | Ibn Ismail | May 31, 2012 11:28 | 195890 | ||
| 2 | Please Spare Us [67 words] | Tom Dundee | Jun 4, 2012 00:44 | 195890 | |
| 2 | Ironically - The Previous Comment Connecting Sharia to Slavery [498 words] | M. Tovey | Jun 4, 2012 13:03 | 195890 | |
| 1 | Maybe you should do some research before posting comments [120 words] | John Philips | Jun 5, 2012 06:53 | 195890 | |
| 4 | Beautifully Said [73 words] | Stormy | Jun 10, 2012 22:57 | 195890 | |
| 3 | ... Research? [193 words] | Peter Hall | Jun 22, 2012 19:03 | 195890 | |
| 8 | The one who should do some research is you our dear John al-tablighee [571 words] | dhimmi no more | Jun 23, 2012 06:23 | 195890 | |
| 3 | Truly a capsule of the state of affairs [121 words] | stranchan | May 15, 2012 16:43 | 195616 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)