69 million page views

Caliphate, Shmalifate

Reader comment on item: The Caliphate: Updates

Submitted by Andy (United Kingdom), Dec 15, 2005 at 11:56

Yes, but these statements are disingenuous because they makes it seem- by omitting an additional clarifying phrase - that Muslims in general want this return to the 7th. century.

All we non-muslims have learnt about Islamic thinking as a result of events from 9/11 shows this is a a very minority scenario. But the more important point is how mad it makes your "standard" Muslim by making him have to respond by expalining that in the main Muslims do not want a Caliphate.

The wierdness of all this is that no one brought out the straight jacket when Bush declared his decisions over Afghanistan and Iraq were dictated to him directly by God. In a sense the two protagonists, the Islamic fundamentalists of the al Qaeda variety and the fundamentalists Chiristians of America understand each other perfectly. The fundamentalist Christians have convinced themselves they have to defend their religion to the hilt by denouncing evolution and encouraging people to kill abortionists; the Islamists have convinced themsleves they can only preserve their faith by destroying all others. Though in both religions the vast majority of adherents accept their religions have had to adapt to societies changes. The mother Christian Catholic Church sees nothing wrong with evoltion. It has a keen interest in the debate about science and religion.

This problem for religions and the religious has existed for centuries even within Christianity. It is well exemplifed by cultists such as Jehovah's Witnesses (not considered Christians by many Christians because of certain doctrinal differences). The Witnesses have convinced themselves for about 100 years or so that they have to defend every word in the Bible - New and Old Testaments, but especially and strangely the Old, which is in essence the Torah, the Book of Judaism.

In other words, two small microscopic agendas are being thrown at each other at great force while the rest of the world sits by belwildered as to why all this should be the cause of so much heat and so little light, while making the usual mistake of not standing up to say that these issues are periferal to the major concerns of the world such as the protection of the environment and Third World poverty.
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (50) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Muslim Brotherhood, Al-Banna, Hitler and Nazism [862 words]CarlosFeb 4, 2023 19:22292124
Someone made a correction to vile Arab Nazi drawing on Berlin [93 words]DalitDec 5, 2022 02:26289385
1The Caliphate of Europe [271 words]Joe KeysorMar 2, 2006 11:4338648
caliphate will RULE!!!!! [33 words]TerriFeb 11, 2007 18:0938648
"Freedom to run around naked on the beach and live immoral and decadent lifestyles" [44 words]Anon.Apr 1, 2019 15:0838648
world jihad is a fact [96 words]Jose AmramFeb 11, 2006 01:4134872
Let there be a caliphate [150 words]G.BisvasFeb 10, 2006 07:4034780
Hitler, Nazi-Islamic SS Divisons & Grand Mufti Amin Al Husseini [107 words]Chard JeromeJan 20, 2006 02:0932043
Exactly [161 words]DaisyFeb 22, 2006 10:0132043
root cause analysis [957 words]allen smithJan 9, 2006 23:1831372
1Ignorance, high birth rate & deceit. [383 words]tonyFeb 8, 2006 21:5231372
Moderate Muslims [59 words]Gerry BurkeApr 21, 2006 11:2231372
high Birth rate [131 words]charmaine federipeJul 26, 2007 09:1531372
PROBLEMS AND COURSES OF HIGH BIRTH RATE IN EAST AFRICA. [22 words]elibariki ezekielNov 1, 2008 11:1331372
Economic recession and birth rate palava in Africa [44 words]Giwa Felix KingMay 5, 2009 02:1331372
More Sound Than Fury [246 words]Rakshas 10 AnanDec 30, 2005 11:5430786
no sound & no fury [94 words]Taimur BegJan 8, 2006 15:3230786
A whole lot of fury [140 words]Raja WahidJan 22, 2006 22:3230786
Last episode in Millenial War [579 words]marisolDec 28, 2005 10:5330693
the Muslim Community of Western Suburbs (MCWS) of Detroit, Terrorism, and the Islamic States of America [76 words]AviDec 23, 2005 17:0730469
Two small reasons to hope [300 words]GermainDec 23, 2005 14:0830459
Suicide [36 words]Richard McGaheyDec 20, 2005 14:3430269
Politically Incorrect - More of the Same! [99 words]Heather ClarkDec 19, 2005 22:3230222
Bushworld vs. the Caliphate [360 words]Ethan BogerDec 19, 2005 18:5730215
Who Has Been Harmed by Enforcement of the Patriot Act [84 words]Julian Tepper, host, The Tepper Show, AM570 WTNT, Bethesda/WashingtonDec 19, 2005 08:4430180
They don't like our freedom [ GWBushjr.] [62 words]Duane M ThomasDec 18, 2005 14:4730146
"fantasies" [13 words]JedDec 18, 2005 09:4530135
Robert Dreyfuss of the Middle East Institute poo-poohs caliphate idea [154 words]Mark JamesDec 17, 2005 22:2730121
A Vacuum of Tensions [108 words]Mourad AntoineDec 17, 2005 20:0930120
Terrorists' goal of a caliphate receiving attention in high places [104 words]Mark JamesDec 16, 2005 23:5930102
Islam and the Pentagon [217 words]Always On WatchDec 15, 2005 20:4330045
Prof. Shibley Telhami and his "facts" [198 words]Bob MillerDec 15, 2005 17:5930039
Difference between British occupation and USA 'liberalization' [110 words]JB SutartoFeb 7, 2006 02:0930039
Caliphate [83 words]JackDec 15, 2005 17:3130037
Iran's countdown [169 words]CristianoJan 7, 2006 08:4730037
Don't miff the mufti [268 words]BBJun 10, 2007 12:3330037
At last [105 words]MoorahshDec 15, 2005 16:1630032
Who is going to be the first caliph of the West ? [177 words]IanusDec 15, 2005 16:1530031
Sharia Law [143 words]Sharia LawDec 15, 2005 15:5830029
1THE ISLAM TABOO [96 words]DONVANDec 15, 2005 13:2630016
Sharia Law in the West [211 words]David SternlightDec 15, 2005 13:1230013
An Unending War [178 words]Julian Tepper, Host, The Tepper Show, AM570 WTNT, Bethesda/Washington, Saturday Nights 8 tDec 15, 2005 13:0430009
The Caliphate [514 words]David SternlightDec 15, 2005 12:5530007
To see thyselves [64 words]MirrorJan 17, 2006 20:5330007
Caliphate, Shmalifate [369 words]AndyDec 15, 2005 11:5629998
Caliphate and Dhimmitude [284 words]Martin IsselDec 15, 2005 11:5629997
On Caliphate [308 words]Ghulam MuhammedDec 15, 2005 11:4229996
There are no varying shades of calipate-the riddle of the "four men" [148 words]Ed BrophyDec 14, 2005 13:3429956
Experts [99 words]Michael TownsDec 14, 2005 09:0029941
Caliphate - Sharia Law [430 words]Heather ClarkDec 14, 2005 02:3229926

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)