69 million page views

The Islamic tradition and al-khara' wa al-istinja' and other sordid matters

Reader comment on item: Istinja' with the Torah and New Testament
in response to reader comment: corrupted

Submitted by dhimmi no more (United States), Sep 28, 2010 at 18:18

Our dear Abdellah Another victim of Arabian imperialism

Oh are you aware our dear Abdellah that your Allah says

wa ma arsalna men rasulan ila bilisani qawmihi

So who was the rasul that was sent to your qawm? Any guesses?

For the readers: I suspect that it would be surprising to most of you but the Islamic tradition has strange pre-occupation with matters of the bowel be it al-khara' (feces or stools) and al-istinja' or the act of cleaning after defecation and with so much orthopraxy in Islam this sujbect is the real deal

> first of all sorry for my english!!i never explaned kindly that bible are corrupted! i was explaning the fatwa that was very bad translated! now they deleted the phrase who were really added from the mind of the translator, but it still has a lot of translation problems!what we must say immediately is that as a muslim who can read arabic, i understand that i cannot clean my self with bible!! because first i dont know what is corrupted or notn and second because there is a lot of sacred names : god, jesus, maria etc.about corruption : it is said in our tradition that it's changed from the original! it's said too that there is jesus bible! who dont exist in the actual version of the bible! and in the same time! there is some diffrences between diffrent christian mouvements versions! But the more important is that we thing that a big part from the bible is true! so we understand the coran and the story of the world by reading the bible!!

For the readers: Most of you make too much out of fatwas as in actual fact a fatwa is no more than a religious edict that can be issued by just about any sheikh or Muslim cleric that can read and write where the sheikh is telling who ever is listening his own view of a subject in the vast orthopraxy literature of Islam and in most cases such fatwas do not mean very much and have very limited audience

And at times the ridiculous reigns supreme and where would you find except in islam where we have what i would regard as a mega fatwa where an Egyptian shiekh wrote a fatwa that was a booklet about the allowed sexual positions is Islam (see Amr Adeeb's al-Qahira al-Yum)! Sobhanallah

The root of the word yafti or he issues a fatwa is FTW and what is most amazing is that in Egyptian Arabic the term inta bitifti (in Modern Classical Arabic it would be inaka tafti) or you are issuing a fatwa is a form of sarcasm! as many Muslims cannot stomach this nonsense.

So much for fatwas

One more point Islamic theology is about

1. The A

2. But not the A

3. And if nothing works then it is Allahu a3lam or only Allah knows and this fatwa is a case in point

So let me translate the first part of this fatwa:

"Insulting the Torah or the Injiil (read this as the NT) that is not corrupted or the corrupted that has a truth or some great name as in the case of the name of allah and who makes that (insult) with knowledge and his choice he brought infidelity (kufr) and seek refuge in allah and that is known that is corrupted or changed from the two (the Torah and the NT) and there is nothing great in it there is no problem with insulting it"

The syntax is a bit confusing but you get the idea

Then he quotes a reference from a certain al-Shams al-Ramli and for the readers most of these qutoes are not for real and i will do a search to check the primary source quoted but i have not been able to locate it in Arabic so far and it is called Nihayat al-muhtaj

"said al-shams al-ramli in nihayat al-muhtaj not allowed al-istinja' by the respected or part of it and the respected are many types among them what was written in it something from the sciences (read this as kutub al-turath al-islami or the books of Islamic tradition) example the hadith and al-fiqh (read this as Islamic law) and there was (there is word here that I was unable to read and it looks like alif and lam and a teh marbouta ilah may be?). not respected like (books) of philosophy the Torah and the injiil (read this as the NT) science and made corrupted and made of it great name al-istija' is allowed with it. End"

So now back to the confused Islamic theology:

A. The A here is

1. the Qur'an tells us that the NT and the Torah and the zabour (read this as the Psalms of David) are Allah's words

2. The Qur'an also says that no one can change Allah's words

3. which means that based on 1 no one can corrupt the Bible which means that the Bible cannot be corrupted which means that it cannot be used for al-istinja'

4. But the ultimate hypocricy is that muslims tell us that we can find Muhammd's name in the "corrupted Bible (the Biblical comforter) or even in the sira we have the Syriac Munahimanna so how come the Jews and Christins kept the name of Muhammad in their books any guesses?

5. and here is your bonus for today our dear Abdellah how come Allah was unable to stop the Jews and Christians from corruting his words any guesses?

And this is the A and it means that no one can use the Torah or the injiil for al-istinja'

B. Now not the A

1. We are also told that the Jews and the Christians, as ridiculous as it sounds, harafu or corrupted their books

2. Therefore their books can be insulted and can be used for al-istinja'

3. But the real question is how about pages that let us say have the name of Allah?

So in short he who wants to use the Torah or the injiil for al-istinja' he must first remove and preserve the paper where he finds the name of Allah

C. Now the only allahu a3lam here is that you are darn to do it and you are darn not to do it

et voila boys and girls one gem from the annals of Islam

>and in all ways we dont know what is "Corrupted" so (as it said in the original fatwa) i cannot clean my self if i'm not sure!my message was clear? or you have questions ?

I urge you to leave Islam and be free again

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (47) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Whatever Happened to Dena Milany? [5 words]Geoffrey GomersallApr 10, 2015 17:12222801
2this story about torah istinja bible [49 words]AmaalMar 4, 2013 23:37204040
How Crazy Is This Nonsense? [30 words]AmboydukeApr 8, 2011 12:33184075
it's a book.... [33 words]fezApr 9, 2011 03:35184075
Alternative to screenshots for viewing old versions of websites [113 words]James ForsythDec 27, 2010 19:25181306
4bigotry [109 words]Peter HerzSep 28, 2010 05:33178768
4Ahamdinejad follows this [49 words]Peter HerzSep 26, 2010 15:14178714
13I have seen this practice myself [39 words]GarySep 22, 2010 10:57178570
4All's fair in love and war [147 words]Rebecca MouldsSep 22, 2010 09:27178569
3It started in the 7th century AD [158 words]Kepha HorSep 25, 2010 23:26178569
1praise [40 words]siegfriedNov 19, 2010 00:31178569
4Is It Not Plain Enough Yet? [153 words]M. ToveySep 21, 2010 19:03178538
How true [3 words]Kepha HorSep 26, 2010 00:04178538
3traduction big troubles [124 words]abdellah lasriSep 21, 2010 18:24178536
3no difference [144 words]the Grand Infidel of KaffiristanSep 25, 2010 21:00178536
4Where are the Old and New Testaments corrupted [733 words]Kepha HorSep 26, 2010 00:02178536
translation big problems [179 words]abdellah lasriSep 27, 2010 10:20178536
corrupted [214 words]abdellah lasriSep 27, 2010 10:38178536
2What We Have Here is a Failure to Communicate. [403 words]M. ToveySep 27, 2010 12:29178536
1Again, no evidence [187 words]Kepha HorSep 28, 2010 05:28178536
10The Islamic tradition and al-khara' wa al-istinja' and other sordid matters [1111 words]dhimmi no moreSep 28, 2010 18:18178536
to dhimmi no more [546 words]abdellah lasriSep 29, 2010 03:06178536
2use Scotts - it's a lot softer [320 words]the Grand Infidel of KaffiristanSep 29, 2010 03:28178536
3Islamic ... [152 words]dhimmi no moreSep 29, 2010 07:21178536
1There is No Corruption of Absolute Truth - Only Corruption in the Human Handling of It. [681 words]M. ToveySep 29, 2010 17:40178536
1the Greatly Disturbed [122 words]the Grand Infidel of KaffiristanSep 30, 2010 05:36178536
Do Try Reading Several Bibles Side By Side [385 words]D.K.Milgrim-HeathSep 30, 2010 08:30178536
1Islam and fatwas and the absurd [153 words]dhimmi no moreOct 1, 2010 07:00178536
2More about the fatwa and the funny istinja' [1234 words]dhimmi no moreOct 2, 2010 08:43178536
1another excellent example of cofusion [148 words]the Grand Infidel of KaffiristanOct 2, 2010 22:15178536
2Abdella cannot be an Arab [147 words]dhimmi no moreOct 4, 2010 07:20178536
By the Way - Understanding The Holy Bible is Hard Without the Spirit [127 words]M. ToveyOct 4, 2010 19:46178536
1running & hiding [103 words]the Grand Infidel of KaffiristanOct 5, 2010 03:32178536
Furthering Understanding - Why Islam MUST Oppose the Holy Bible [362 words]M. ToveyOct 6, 2010 18:32178536
Yes, your comments are clear [877 words]Kepha HorOct 11, 2010 18:44178536
1I've taken your advice [156 words]Kepha HorOct 12, 2010 17:09178536
1corruption of islam [58 words]yehudaNov 4, 2010 11:16178536
I am back [154 words]Debanjan BanerjeeDec 1, 2010 21:15178536
But What Have you Learned From Reading the HOLY BIBLE [201 words]M. ToveyDec 5, 2010 20:41178536
My learning of HOLY BIBLE is given below [251 words]Debanjan BanerjeeDec 6, 2010 20:55178536
3Our dear Deb is worried about our native people but does he worry about his own Hindu ancestors? [108 words]dhimmi no moreDec 8, 2010 07:53178536
Dig Deeper in the Hebrew Holy Bible for Its Truth in Your Life [733 words]M. ToveyDec 8, 2010 19:12178536
The True Message of the Torah and the New Testament - Love of Almighty God [724 words]M. ToveyDec 15, 2010 11:04178536
1The exception or the rule? [51 words]Alain Jean-MairetSep 21, 2010 14:40178524
5Arabic word: "istinja' " [66 words]Charlie GriffithSep 21, 2010 12:59178515
4islam [41 words]seraphimeSep 21, 2010 10:26178509
11muslims have been brainwashed to hate the Bible, Torah, Christians, Jews, Israel, non muslims. [87 words]Phil GreendSep 21, 2010 04:31178499

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)