No we do not want to exclude productive muslims from our economic & social fabric

Submitted by Proud Indian (India), Aug 27, 2008 at 04:21

Dear Nishi,

I hope you stop harping as a politician. when i specifically wrote that indians have accepted muslim actors / industrialists / sportspersons whole heartedly, then were is the question of excluding them from the economic and social fabric of the nation? it is very wrong on your part to blame indians for that. .. you didnt read my post carefully it seems..

i myself would be proud to work for a company like wipro or staying next to any of our loved muslim sportsmen... you seem to ignore comments which i make but highlight the ones which you seem to understand as islamophobe.. just like pseudo secular politicians like our country who are only interested in pandering to the stupid radicals... The fact is that muslims are better off in India even thouhh they are in minority than hindus or other faiths who are in minority in muslim countries..

now let me pose a question to you..SIMI has been confirmed as the masterminds behind the bomb blasts, now isn't that sedition? Where are all the pseudo secularists who jumped in glee and were happy when the ban was lifted? i know they must be shamelessly hiding thier faces ! with regards to RSS AND BAJRANG DALS members caught with fake beards and muslim garbs .. please send us the links so that we can read for ourselves... no hearsay please and Also which lukhnow trail you are talking about?

with regards to the members who died while making bombs.. serves them right! just ask yourself one question.. why aren't any human rights organistaions lining up thier doorsteps to take up thier cases ? i know why, they arent muslims thats why. Maharashtra is ruled by the secular congress party.. why are they pussy footing along? in my earlier reply when you had posted that Bal Thackrey had called for hindu human bombs... do you see any ? Nishi, we are not that barbaric.. I have already told you that if hindus would work on the principle of TIT for TAT then you would see godhras happening after every bomb blast.

whats happening in kashmir? do you think we will give whats legimately ours on a platter to the Pakistanis or the seperatists? aren't the local population who want to breakway from the country or join pakistan traitors? what about the rights of the kashmiri pandits out there? you had shamelessly written that they are cowards that is why they leave. what was the other option nishi? should they have fought back and slaughtered muslims as it happened in godhra? should the hindus take it as a holy war and send armed youths to kashmir to single out local muslims? WRONG AGAIN i hope that doesn't happen and i know it wont!

i have time and again reminded all the so called sympathisers & apologists that if the muslims are productive to the nation and stay within the laws of the land, i do not see a conflict and they will be accepted by the majority.. ( they have already been accepted!!!).. The minute they start thinking that they are a privileged lot and their religious laws should supercede the law of the land , there are bound to be conflicts..

Also let me clarify once and for all . I AM NOT A BUSH FAN. he is the worst thing that could have happened to USA. it seems you have not read my post " which propoganda of the west am i believing in?" with regards to your suggestion for reading books.. i suggest you to do the same first.. and dont believe in the politicians who project muslims as victims of the system. Facts speak for themselves..

I know you are one of those people who choose to downgrade the majority just to prove your secular credentials. i do work with muslim colleagues and i really wouldn't mind even reporting to a muslim who is intellectually and experience wise better than me.. i am an athiest and i dont believe in religion.. but if someone chooses to claim that his religion is greater than mine or someone else then the hindu in me rises up!Nishi i stay in a muslim locality and i know how the dynamics work when the population demography changes to muslim majority.. i had wriiten in my posts how there is trouble in our locality during diwali celebrations.. you didn't comment on that?

I once again urge you to drop your pseudosecular views and if you are an indian as you claim to be , start seeing the bigger picture

Thanks & regards,

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".