To Salah Ali:

Submitted by The Last Prophet (United States), May 26, 2009 at 23:15

Salah Ali, your answers are taqqiya at its finest.

Salah Ali:"when you say Moslems should never have been there, you speak of Islam as a race or an ethnic entity."

For your information, neither Islam nor Muslims are a race, but Muslims use the idea for manipulative purposes.

Salah Ali:"People adopt beliefs thoughts and practices which they feel good or acceptable. The only people who were brought back to Islam by the edge of the sword were the apostats of Arabian peninsula."

Though there is no denying some guillible people converted on their own, Islam was spread in the middle east and other places mainly by sword and marriages.

Salah Ali:"As for Jiziah it is a task imposed on all be they Moslems or Christians. The difference is in terms. When it is imposed on Moslems it is Zakat, when it is imposed on non-Moslems, it is Jeziah."

Zakat is "alms for the poor" and jizya is a tax levied on non-Muslim citizens, so they are two different things.

Salah Ali:"Moreover, Islam does not negate other religions or replaced them. I ask you a question had the Jews of Medina or Khaiber embraced Islam? Had the Christians of Nineveh or Najran embraced Islam. Definitely not. They kept to their own religion."

If Islam did not replace Christanity in Iraq, Egypt and Syria, how come these are Islamic countries now? Those Christians and Jews could keep their religion because of Jizya.

Salah Ali:"I look and see and have all the documents that prove that both Zionism and USA hooligans who used WMD or gangs like Blackwater are criminals."

So you seem to think that Hamas, Taliban, Hezabollah and all other terriorists are virtuous!

Salah Ali:"Who said Meccan Chapters of the Qur'an did not call to violence with non-believers. Even Watt and Richard Bell do not say that. I advice you go to Western studies of the Qur'an before you are entangled with concepts and ideas which lie beyond your grasp. There are cognitive aspects of love and the Holy Book of Allah teaches us both love and peace."

Though the Quran has some peaceful verses, mostly it preaches hate and violence.

Salah Ali:"It is you who brought destruction and materialistic ideologies. It is you who disseminate corruption and permissiveness."

Islam is the most materialistic cult ever. For example, Islam promises wine, houris and other sensual things in heaven. You are wrong when you say there is no corruption and permissiveness in Islamic countries. For example, Pakistan is a very corrupt islamic country and in Saudi Arabia, the elite is permitted vice.

Salah Ali:"islam teaches us cleanliness of the body and soul while you smell of terrible stinch."

If that so, how come muslims in general are one of the dirtiest people on the planet?

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".