re: A Muslim

Submitted by true believer (India), May 29, 2006 at 04:59

>You said "But rights are being broken everywhere in the world, one cannot point fingers at entire populations of people for the sins of a few"

When entire populations support and approve of the sins of a few among them, they will be rightly blamed for their actions.

>You said " Take a look at the millions of arabs and muslims killed everyday in Iraq, Palestine and Cherchneya"

If that had indeed been the case, it would have solved the Palestinian problem for Israel. Millions were killed in the Iran Iraq war when Khomenei and Saddam were in power and they fought each other for eight years from 1980 - 88. The chechen population was around one million when the conflict with Russia began. It has only increased now. If Russians had really killed Chechens in millions as you claim, Beslans would never have occured. Millions of moslems were killed when Pakistan began its military crackdown on Bangladesh in 1971.

When I said "In the past arabs have traded black africans as slaves, raped their women and children" I did not deny that whites committed atrocities on blacks.If you read the chain of posts, my post was in reply to self righteous moslems who were accusing others of slavery , as if moslems never had a part in it.

>You also claim "Islam came to the arabs 1400 years ago and forbade slavery" .

If that was the case why did Mohammed's wives keep slaves ? Islam did not stop moslems from trading blacks as slaves. Islam cannot stop moslems from killing blacks in Darfur today. Chanting Bilal , Bilal won't help much.

> You said "In america, non-christian people are kidnapped and crucified by christian extremists."

This is the biggest tripe have come across on this forum till date. Even Al Qaida does not propogate such ridiculous myths. I understand that there are physchos and all kinds of weird cults in the US, and they do all sorts of crazy things. It reminds me that century back Jews were falsely accused of such things, but at least people in those days were ignorant. You dont have that excuse. This sounds like mollah propoganda of misinformation. Man they expect people to believe it ;-) You need not point me to some phoney website maintained by Christ-bashing moslems to justify this.

>You said "Islam strictly forbids the killing/raping/harming of an innocent person, of any ethnicity or colour"

The problem here is that islam doesnot consider non-moslems as innocent. Even if it does it does seem to not treat them that way.

>You said "Europeans live in a first world, wealthy society, they have the resources and money in order to provide for the less wealthy. Check up on any Arab or muslim country, they are all considered third world countries, much like your own, in debt and run without much democracy"

Do you really mean that the oil rich moslems nations in the Persian Gulf are poor ? They are dirt rich but a few sheikhs have grabbed all the wealth instead of distributing it evenly. And nothing prevents these "impoversihed" oil-rich nations from putting billions of dollars into funding jehadis across the globe. They can very well spare a few pennies for the poor. The very fact that your countries can fund training of pilots to knock down buildings proves it.

> You said "There are many political hands that benefit from this distorted image af a peaceful religion, that has remained peaceful every since it was established 1400 years ago"

Mohammed benefitted 1400 years back, mollas are being benefitted now.I am tired of replying to this crap about peace again and again. Just surf some of the other articles and use your intelligence to know that peace and islam are mutually exclusive.

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".