To scholar: Again please don't put words in my mouth

Submitted by Lisa (Canada), Nov 30, 2005 at 23:05

=="Lisa is telling us that the Quran is false because Taha Hussein (a famous Egyptian literary figure) after 1300 years was able to challenge it! Well, it sounds like a very long time to me to challenge a book! Maybe he wrote a new one, and we never heard of it!! Lisa, why don't you share with us part of Taha Hussein's master work? I wonder, if coming up with a new Quran is that easy, why we can't find hundreds of versions of it, just as is in the case of the bible!"==

I said Quran is false and I went through lots of explanation on why I thought this way, read my previous statements again. I was replying to Randa when she said that no one could challange the Quran, I said that Taha Hussien one of many who challanged the Quran and also i said that bedwins in Jahiliya until today are the best poets, many of Jahiliya's poems can not be challanged. Again scholar, the kew here is not in how you write is in what you write

==Let me tell you something, the Quran will always remain what it has always been throughout the years, a miracle. To appreciate its uniqueness, you have to read it in its original form in Arabic! ==

Guess what, Arabic is my first language, I was born in Arabic country and lived most of my life there, I have learned the Quran, hadith and sira in Arabic. I love Arabic songs, Arabic music, Arabic poems, however, I find Quran even in its original language a book full of contradiction, and difinately not a divine message. I don't see any music or rythym in Quran.
Quran is not a miracle and will never be so.

Peace be with you

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".