For Pir Sahab and Islam is the religion of the Arabs! part trois!

Submitted by dhimmi no more (United States), Nov 26, 2006 at 08:46

My dear Pir Sahab you wrote:

>I am not a tablighee I am just a Muslim

Then why are you here?And what is that Pir thing?Wanna share?

Snip for sabab al-ikhtisar oh you do not know Arabic I mean brevity

Then your intellectual dishonesty comes to the surface as you wrote:

>you either speak Al Quran Al Kareem or you say Quran Kareem

But my dear Pir you wrote in your original post: >Quran Hakeem

Why is the change of mind and now it is Quran Kareem and not Hakeem? Did you realize that you were mangling the Arabic language? and do you think that I did not notice this sudden change?

I will disregard your poor transliteration. Then you wrote:

>Quran ee Kareem

May be in Pakistan but no Arab or even your Allah himself will know what you are talking about! So why do you mangle a language that you do not know? If you would have written "the generous Qur'an" I would have had more respect for you but you did not. Why is that my dear Pir?

And you know what? There is an old saying: "old civilizations are not conjured away" The voices of your ancestors come out loud and clear in the no definite article, the no hamza sound in Qur'an, and the ee thing. Islam and the Arabs brutalized your ancestors but it seems that your ancestors have the last laugh.

>all are the same

May be in your little fantasy world but you are mangling a language that you do not know and is central to understanding the religion of the Arabs!

>I think you know the history of Islam

Very well including reading Michael Cook.

>so you may know also Hazrat ee Bilal eee Habashi

Again the voices of your ancestors that were brutalized by Islam and the Arabs and their language come across loud and clear.

1. There is no Arabic word called Hazrat. The Arabs have the word: Hadrat and the ee and eee have no meaning in Arabic. Remember? Old civilizations are not conjured away. Oh well

2. The above sentence in Arabic would be translated to proper Arabic as: Hadrat al-mua'then Bilal al-Habashi and it is still very ackward. I see Bilal called in Muslim literature: Bilal that is it. Only Pakistanis have this obsession with Hazrat!

You know this fractured sentence or yours reminds me of Firdawsi's Shahnemah and that Arabian imperialism and the language of the arabs cannot overcome an old civilization.

I find it amusing that you are out to defend and spread the religion of the Arabs and Arabian imperialsim but you know what? The ultimate humiliation of the Arabs and their imperialsim is that the sounds and voices of your ancestors that were brutlaized by Muslims are loud and clear in your mangled Urdu/Arabic. Shame.

Stay tuned for more

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".