69 million page views

comment

Reader comment on item: How Can Israel Win the Palestinian Conflict?

Submitted by David (United States), Jan 7, 2023 at 21:45

First, I would like to compliment the author for consistency. This was the position articulated by him years ago in an editorial at NRO. I had been under the impression that his position has since radically shifted. In an era when many people are prone to quickly shun prior viewpoints for one reason or another, it is gratifying to see someone who is not succumbing to this temptation.

I personally have a somewhat different view of the ways to resolve the conflict, although I hesitate to articulate them in detail at the moment. I'll just make a few observations.

1. It does seem urgent, for the purpose of advancing any solution at all, to resolve the issue of Gaza first. And it also seems possible, since Israel has no land disputes with Gazans in particular. Placing the strip under Egyptian rule again would seem, indeed, like a most worthy idea. Another idea, perhaps sure to come under greater objection from Cairo: double the size of the Strip to El Arish, which still serves the vital purpose of an entry and exit point insofar as air travel.

2. The Jordanian peace treaty cannot be assumed to be permanent, nor can the monarchy.

3. Regarding Ben Gvir and Smotrich, it would seem that the author's characterization of their opinions is more or less consistent with formerly articulated views from each, respectively, with the caveat that Ben Gvir has been promoting rather different ideas during his rise as a prominent public figure this year. His focus at the moment is primarily on security within the Green Line, and on the issue of security writ large, and he regularly pronounces "I do not anymore believe that Israel needs to expel all Arabs, just the terrorists..."
Understanding the author's position that a country cannot "achieve victory" over its citizenry, I beg to differ on this critical point. It would not be onerous for the terms of Israel's social compact with its Arab minority to include absolute prohibition on any effort on their part, to destroy the state. Insisting on this would certainly not be inconsistent with the prevailing norms in the region, but it would also not mark Israel as a particularly illiberal country. As has been often noted, democracy is not, and need not, be a suicide pact.

This itself, is very likely the central question regarding the entire conflict. I would venture to say that Israel can prevail over the Arab population in the pre or post 1967 borders under either of the main ideas promulgated as "solutions," provided that the majority that founded the country, remains united in a belief in its national purpose. This seems ancillary but I think it is the very heart of the current dilemma.

Regarding Smotrich, indeed he is taking some steps that would seem to pave the way toward an extension of sovereignty, although they are fitful and measured ones at the moment: removing the responsibility of the military over the residents of the area and transferring some authorities to respective government agencies. Part of the objective is to prevent the takeover of open space in the unsettled regions near the Jewish communities and in the Jordan Valley. I'll differ with the author as to the importance of these areas for Israel's security and future, adopting the view that they are quite important for a host of reasons.

In the name of prudence and additional contemplation, I will refrain from outlining my personal concept for how to resolve the dispute, except to say that perhaps some elements have not outright been rejected by the author when proposed by others in the past.

At the moment though, it is hard to overlook the situation in Amman. It seems likely that something is changing there, and the tone of the country's relationship with Israel will accordingly change very soon. So it appears at least to me, and I'd be curious for the author's observation. It would seem probable that Israel may need to erect a physical barrier near the Jordan River in the near future. Whether it is prudent for Israel to continue placing its efforts into the continuation of the current government there seems like an important question. It is not something I can personally answer, as I do not know the extent to which Israel is equipped to contend with the multiple security challenges that it confronts. It would seem, though, that change there will have dramatic ramifications. Perhaps Israel would be wise to begin working with Jordanian Palestinians instead of the Bedouin supported rulers. Ultimately they may be more willing to enter the arrangement the author seems to prefer, or could favor other ideas. I don't think that the developments there, however, can be ignored. I wonder if the author is implying otherwise? Namely that events will proceed as normal? It seems to me that the monarch is under enormous strain, and is also not an ally of Israel in any way. It is also beyond clear that he does not want the West Bank. He wants Jerusalem, without the remainder.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Daniel Pipes replies:

Thanks for the compliment on consistency.

1. Trouble is, Cairo is not eager to take control of Gaza.

2. Agree.

3. How does a democratic government defeat its own citizens? Sounds like an oxymoron to me.

Reader comments (47) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
2Re-Conquer Gaza & Impose Social Engineer with Israeli Arabs & West Bankers [188 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
RobertFeb 11, 2023 23:57292938
Hossein Karaka cold blooded murder: Feb.10.23 rammnig attack, and racist "Palestinian" praise [591 words]AharonFeb 10, 2023 12:40292792
Pure souls... victims of child killers racist Arab - Islamic bigotry [262 words]AharonFeb 12, 2023 06:44292792
2We need to directly blame Islam for the murders by Muslims [116 words]PrashantFeb 12, 2023 10:35292792
4The root cause of islamic violence & terrorism [163 words]aktFeb 14, 2023 03:20292792
Islamofascist Raja Abdulrahim strikes again in her NYT piece: white washing racist massacre on innocent Jews [20 words]SallyFeb 5, 2023 10:52292162
Lying "Palestinian" from Gaza propogates on the "Forward?" [73 words]SallyFeb 2, 2023 06:53291965
Arab Pallywood, the bigot Abeer Salman and vile cartoons [18 words]AharonJan 30, 2023 18:04291856
The racist Arab Islamic fascist Alkam Khairy's massacre in front of synagogue: Jerusalem, Jan 27, 2023 [4607 words]AharonJan 30, 2023 13:30291846
1For Islam violence is just an idiom [308 words]PrashantFeb 1, 2023 06:00291846
Jewish Israel in the Context of Christian Russia and Muslim Iran [104 words]RobertJan 29, 2023 08:57291788
22023 1-28 "In Israel, India, and Elsewhere the Civilization State is Taking Over" [92 words]RobertJan 28, 2023 20:45291769
12020-2023 "Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism" [282 words]RobertJan 25, 2023 20:51291622
1Self-Hating Jew Kenneth Roth Gets Fellowship at Harvard University [434 words]RobertJan 23, 2023 12:03291490
1Tough and direct question for people like Kenneth Roth [175 words]PrashantJan 24, 2023 23:57291490
2Kenneth Roth, of Human Rights Watch, and Harvard University [357 words]RobertJan 21, 2023 08:02291356
1That is why we, the people, need to capture the bandwidth. [173 words]PrashantJan 21, 2023 21:26291356
11980 [2017] "Close Settlement on the Land" by Eugene V. Rostow [197 words]RobertJan 20, 2023 16:59291335
1Sergey Lavrov and Antisemite Ken Roth (of Human Rights Watch) [232 words]RobertJan 19, 2023 12:44291266
Anti-Zionism and Anti-semitism is not what Islam follows. [264 words]PrashantJan 20, 2023 02:15291266
1Treason and Citizenship [337 words]RobertJan 16, 2023 16:32291104
2We don't want to become like them but... [160 words]PrashantJan 17, 2023 08:59291104
12,000+ Years in Other People's Countries, ... and Now What to Do with Area C. [328 words]RobertJan 15, 2023 21:04291058
Minister Zohar: "There were thousands at the [lefty] demonstration, [but] millions at the election" [52 words]NirJan 15, 2023 00:59291030
28.1% Muslim Population of Israel [633 words]RobertJan 13, 2023 15:05290976
118.1% not 8.1% (Muslim Population of Israel) - Sorry for the typo. [46 words]RobertJan 14, 2023 12:47290976
1Thanks Robert, can I add... [31 words]NirJan 15, 2023 00:52290976
118% muslims is the beginning of the danger zone for democracies [201 words]PrashantJan 16, 2023 11:08290976
"Palestinian" policeman/terrorist - eliminated (Jan.12.23) [25 words]NirJan 12, 2023 03:54290906
"I prefer for Jordan to run the West Bank" [18 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
DenisJan 10, 2023 06:18290829
Minister Akunis: "The fact that they (LEFT) are losing does not mean that democracy is in danger" [388 words]AharonJan 9, 2023 21:38290808
State of Israel presents: Discrimination of Jews in the Galilee settlements - From reasons of conservatives' rise in Israel [1388 words]AharonJan 9, 2023 16:49290795
Rule "a democratic government cannot defeat its citizen" has a qualifier [259 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
PrashantJan 8, 2023 23:32290759
You are right. [68 words]PrashantJan 18, 2023 23:13290759
2Ideology and Victory [778 words]DaveJan 8, 2023 10:05290726
Time to bring back the short-wave radio. [140 words]PrashantJan 8, 2023 23:48290726
2I read Dave's letter twice to learn from it. [377 words]PrashantJan 9, 2023 04:19290726
1The Buddhists can surprise you [69 words]DaveJan 9, 2023 10:32290726
1Good points [59 words]Gary KatzJan 8, 2023 00:13290699
comment [846 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
DavidJan 7, 2023 21:45290697
Three Issues; Jordan, Jordan, & Jordan [462 words]RobertJan 8, 2023 13:39290697
1Regarding Jordan's peace treaty and other treaties with Islamic politico-religious regimes [233 words]PrashantJan 8, 2023 23:11290697
2denying facts [203 words]adel saoumaJan 7, 2023 21:27290696
2Policy, Strategy, and Tactics [205 words]RobertJan 7, 2023 14:51290686
2The realities in a nutshell [144 words]G MarcusJan 7, 2023 20:36290686
2I like the 3-state solution as long as... [91 words]PrashantJan 8, 2023 04:07290686
2Muslims need to be defeated in the war for the bandwidth [397 words]PrashantJan 8, 2023 22:00290686

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)