we judge islam by its actual results among muslims

Submitted by G.Vishvas (India), Mar 18, 2008 at 03:29

Respected Bilawal

Your response is typical for a person who is (pro-islamically) indocrinated and close-minded. It contains the same catchy phrases which muslims juggle and toggle amongst themselves. You could have at least saved the situation for yourself by putting the phrase "I believe that..." in front of the grand claims and statements that you make. Instead, you present them as if they are proven unquestionable indomitable verified established truths. This is how you muslims fall into the trap laid out by your leaders and teachers and wish that everyone fall into this same trap. Your leaders and teachers are themselves a trapped people - trapped by their own older-leaders and older-teachers of the past.

You muslims think god can be trapped in the kuran by Mohammad and you can go on using that same trick for all times to come on all people.

Islam is based on fear, intimidation and seductions. Islam means submission means mental slavery. Mental slavery under an 7th century arabic-tribal god-concept.

If anyone wishes to write a book to manipulate timid humans of low socio-political intelligence then he can take the kuran as an example to be imitated - even if the sentences that he writes are poetically better or worse than those of the kuran. The kuran can impress those who are timid, irrational, have fascsist proclivities. The kuran is of use to those who wish to set up a fascist absolutist state and society in which the timid fascism-oriented irrational people can find shelter (or think they can find shelter).

Kuran's supposedly inimitable style (which is a very subjective viewpoint or the typical statement by indoctrinated adorers) is no argument in favor of its contents. One can have a unique style and yet end up writing foolish things - and that is very likely the case - the more foolish or manipulative the contents the more unique the presentation style.

The arguments which muslims give in favor of kuran and islam are so shabby that I wonder how the muslims themselves do not recognise this shabbiness. Islamic education and intimidation causes muslims to become incapable of recognising their own pro-islamic arguments as shabby.

The god of islam is not a very intelligent or wise or efficient god. So he resorts to terror and intimidation in order to imprison human minds under his control. Actually this god is a creation of Mohammad and this reflects Mohammad's own lack of intelligence, wisdom, honesty and sincerity.

One can judge a human being by the god or gods that he creates or believes in. And, conversely, one can and must judge a god by the human beings that he prefers or selects as his favorites. On both these counts Mohammad, kuran, islam, the kuranic god and muslims are a worsening disaster.

G.Vishvas

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".