reply to Dave

Submitted by Mr.X (Lebanon), Dec 18, 2005 at 09:13

"I'm a little confused. I do not believe, in my heart, that any religion has thrust its followers into any kind of war with non-believers. The problem I believe is the interpretation of the message by individuals who are trusted to present followers with the truth."

Dave i am now Christian and ex-muslim .... this what i used to believe at first place , i thought that i believed in the " real islam" , the " peaceful islam " and not the fake islam interpreted by wahabists or salafists mvts like el Qaeda . But after reading the Qur'aan and hadith and history of Mohammad several times i was totaly disapointed and i discovered myself that i wasnt a real muslim in all my life ...a real muslim must be like osama bin laden ....a killer.

Unlike all prophets , muhammad is the only one who didnt perform any physical miracles , he always said " the Qu'raan is my miracle " ....but why he couldn't do real miracles ?!! He want us to believe that words can be real miracle!! And abt Muhammad's contacts with Christians while he was pagan : Warraqa, a christian monk, the cousin of Khadicha (first wife of Muhammad) ... Zeid the slave another Christian who was raised by Khadija .

Why he was the only one who see revealations in a cave? While all other prophets hear God or angels anywhere !! WHy he must medidate in the cave to hear God and why no one was allowed to enter ? ...what he was hiding there ?!...the christian slave , bible and books maybe?

WHy he was the only prophet who used the sword , and sent men to assissinate people who dislike him like a mafia boss( like Ka'ab a jewish poet who said poems against Muhammad , Muhammad sent 3 of his men to assassinate in secret at night , in secret because there was a peace treaty with the jews , Q1 : How can a prophet of God can be so unmerciful and kill some1 just because he said something bad abt him?? Q2 : How he can disrespect this treaty ??)

Muslims say that Islam is the real religion coz it was the fastest growing religion ...well Aum Shinrikyo the Japanese cult was also Japan's fastest-growing religious group in 1984 , Shōkō Asahara the leader of Aum and who claimed himself as prophet used terrorist ways to expand and to send his message and he trained his followers to use weapons , and he used terrorism to keep his followers (any1 who abondon the cult die) ....hmm sounds familiar ......his ultimate goal was to expand his religion over all the world with force .

But this fake prophet failed because he was stopped by the japanese army , but imagine if Shōkō Asahara lived in the past 2000 years ago .....there' s no strong army to stop him ....so what would be the result?? He would probably succeed to expand with the arms over all Japan ...and maybe China and then all Asia!!!, who knows??read abt this fake prophet here :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aum_Shinrikyo

So in other terms, the term "fastest growing religion " doesnt prove anything ....in the contrast it proves that violence was used to expand so fast .

So Dave i know this is hard to believe but it's the minority of the muslim like el Qaeda who are practicing the real islam and the other muslims still blind ( i was blind too once )

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".