Childish, Dhimmi

Submitted by nura (United States), Jun 11, 2008 at 13:17

Dhimmie,

I will respond this time using your childish technique:

you are really compromising yourself. You are no more than a coward. If you hate your neighbors so much why don't you go to a Tableghee mosque and tell them how much you hate them!! You will never because you are a coward.

Do you have a disorder. Seriously, I study psychology and you are displaying neurotic behavior. Your in denial and continue to insist that I am a Pakistani, a man, it's crazy. I don't know urdu, and thank God my ancestors were not HINDU!!!

Are you sexist? Why do you have a problem believing that I am a woman?

If you knew my religion you would know that it is Haram to pretend to be woman or man if you are not. If I was a man pretending to be a woman, I would be committing a sinful act, which I would never do for the likes of you!

Your Arabic is very bad Dhimmie you keep repeating the same phrases!!! Instead of using the transliteration, why don't you use REAL ARABIC. Can you read Arabic or can you just read transliteration? I'm sure my Arabic is better than yours. YOU ARE THE ARAB WANNABE. You spend allot of time pretending that you know the language.

How old are you 12?

You probably have an Arabic dictionary next to you, lol.

Your "Jesus must be Allah" theory is a real display of your idiocy.

So you are a polytheist if Allah Hates it? Sounds like you are agreeing to his existence!!! WHY WOULD IT MATTER IF THERE IS NO ALLAH DHIMMIE?

You like pork and wine? Be careful you might be eating your great-grandfather according to Hinduism.

Perhaps you are a drunk man living in his mother's basement. Are you old enough to drink?

Do you hear voices?

Why do you care if I celebrate the Prophet's(PBUH) birthday or not? You love my attention don't you?

This is a fatwa about the matter:

The eminent scholar Muhammad Salih bin Uthaimeen was asked concerning the celebration of the birthday of the Messenger of Allah (r), to which he responded:

To begin with, the exact day of birth of the Messenger of Allah (r) is not known with certainty. Rather, some contemporary researchers have confirmed that he died on the 9th of Rabee' al-Awal and not the 12th (as is commonly believed), and thus there is no historical basis for specifying the 12th for celebration.

Furthermore, this celebration has no basis in the religious point of view, since if it was legislated, the Prophet would have performed it or informed his nation to do so. If he had performed it or informed his nation to do so, it would be necessary for it to have been preserved, since Allah (I) says:

"Verily It is We Who have sent down the Dhikr (i.e. the Remembrance of the Qur`an) and surely, We will guard and preserve it (from corruption)." (al-Hijr: 9)

Since this was not narrated, we come to know that it is not from the religion of Allah. If it is not from the religion of Allah, then it is not allowed for us to worship Allah (U) and seek to come close to Him in this manner. If Allah (I) has made a particular path for us to follow to reach Him (and His pleasure), which is the path of the Messenger of Allah , how can it be permissible for us, while we are only slaves, to make another path which leads to Allah's Pleasure from our own selves (and not revealed)? Indeed it is a great transgression against the right of Allah (U) to legislate in His religion that which is not part of it. Moreover, this entails a denial of what Allah (I) said in the Qur`an:

"This day I have perfected your religion for you, completed My Favor upon you, and have chosen for you Islam as your religion" (al- Ma`idah: 3)

If this celebration was from the Perfection of the Religion, it must have been in existence before the death of the Messenger of Allah (r). If it is not from the Perfection of the Religion, then it is not possible that it be from the religion, since Allah (I) said: "This day I have perfected your religion for you." Whoever claims that it is from the Perfection of the Religion which occurred after the death of the Messenger of Allah , then his claim amounts to a denial of this verse of the Qur`an. Without doubt those who celebrate the birthday of the Messenger of Allah , only desire to magnify, extol and praise the Messenger , show their love for him, and increase their enthusiasm to bring out their feelings in this celebration for the Prophet . All of this is a form of worship. The love of the Messenger is a worship that is necessary for faith, since one's faith is not complete until he loves the Messenger more than his own self, his son, his father, and all of humanity. Magnification, exaltation and praise of the Messenger of Allah for Allah's sake is an act of worship and is from the religion, as is enthusiasm for the Messenger of Allah , since they draw one closer to Allah's religion.

Thus it follows that celebration of the birthday of the Prophet in order to draw near to Allah and to extol His Messenger is regarded as an act of worship, and since it is an act of worship then it is never allowed to innovate anything new in religion which is not of it. Therefore, the celebration of the birthday is an innovation and prohibited. Also, we hear various reports that these celebrations contain many unlawful acts, which neither the religion, one's senses, nor any reasonable intelligence deem permissible. They sing rhymes and poems which go to extremes in respect to the Messenger , so much so that they make him greater than Allah, and refuge is sought in Allah. We also hear about the foolishness of some of the participants, that when an orator tells the story of his birth and reaches the part of his delivery, they all stand up in attention together saying and believing that the soul and spirit of the Messenger of Allah , has appeared among them manifest, and that they stand out of respect. This is extreme folly and absurd superstition. Moreover, it is not mannerly to stand up for the Messenger of Allah since he used to dislike that. The Sahaabah, who loved and extolled the Messenger more than anyone else, would not stand for him while he was alive due to his hate for it, so how foolish is this baseless superstition?

The celebration of the birthday of the Messenger of Allah is a blatant innovation which never occurred until after the three righteous generations following the death of the Messenger of Allah , and it is full of undesired and wicked things which oppose the basis of the religion of Islam, moreover the mixing and integration of men and women together in one area and many other objectionable acts.

As Muslims we do not honor one prophet over another, we also do not worship or overly praise our prophets making the mistakes of the Christians. Again, stop pretending you know my religion. I've been in this for 17 years buddy.

1 billion Muslims celebrate it? I don't think so, check your figures again. Even if it were true, it does not make it right.

THERE IS NO HADITH OF THE PROPHET CELEBRATING HIS BIRTHDAY!!! YOU ARE A LIAR!!

AGAIN WHY DO YOU CARE, MUSLIM WANNABE?

That was kinda fun.

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".