Syed Mohammed: If Islam allows loot of losers why are Muslims screaming about what is happening in Iraq?

Submitted by Plato (India), Mar 6, 2008 at 12:31

Syed Mohammed Ali you wrote:

>> what do you mean by honour or demean her? lol thats means anyone who is gentlemen can embedded with your mom ........fine great morality ...and what about my prophet. he is mercy to menkind ...<<

As long as they freely agree to ‘embed' each other, even if I am uncomfortable with it, there is nothing immoral about it except in your Allah's eyes. But what is truly immoral is your prophet taking Safiya to bed hours after torturing her husband to death and killing several of her close relatives. What is immoral is taking to bed a Jewish woman after having her entire menfolk beheaded and the women and children of her tribe sent to the slave markets. What is immoral is asking for the hand of a girl of six from her reluctant father and ‘embedding' her when she was nine.

What is immoral is the Prophet distributing captured women for his favourite companions to enjoy at their will (History of Tabari vol 8 page 29 and 30).

Your prophet a mercy to mankind!?!? Give us a break, my dear Syed!

>>...safiyan husband and parents kill by prophet ..without any reason or for fun that can be the topic debate..<<

Yes let us debate what happened to the mother of believers,Safiya, Syed Muhammad Ali.

>> …debate other thing is that concubines ...was the trends prophet solomon have 700 concubines prophet david have many concubines..<<

David and Solomon (the one who could talk to ants and birds) are Islam's prophet too. The only difference is that Muhammad, the paragon of human virtues, kept fewer concubines than Solomon. You seem to be saying that this was the trend then, so one must accept it. With that logic drinking wine also the trend then, and even now for that matter, so why has alcohol been banned. Taking interest was the trend then and now, why is it banned. All I can understand from your logic is that there is nothing wrong or immoral in keeping any number of concubines. This Islamic morality is not for us unbelievers.

>>...i have check the records..about the divorce rate...in muslim countries far less than the west countries…<<

I will accept it if you can give us the sources to back up your statement.

>>..aiesha's age was 15 years<<

What is comical is Muslims using Islamic mathemagic to conclude Aisha's age is 15 and sometimes using some more powerful magic she is made into a doddering old spinster all of 19 against all the evidence in the hadith and sira. Aisha, who spewed out thousands of hadith, herself claimed she was six when Muhammad married her and nine when she was ‘embedded' by the 53-year-old prophet. If when she was 15 or 19, she thought she was only 9 what value can you place on all those hadith she dispensed left and right?

>>,,,,but what about perverter god name jesus comes out from womb of 12 years old virgin girl ...shame shame christian god is perverter ...<<

Shame on you Syed, Jesus is your prophet too and the Christian god is your god too. Watch out there may be a fatwa allowing your blood soon! And Mary was a virgin (according to your Koran and Bible). A 53 year old granddaddy did not try to pervert or impregnate her.

>>...freedom of slaves ...regards as the good deeds in the quran... <<

If freedom of slaves is a good deed according to the Koran why did Muslim nations have slavery right up to the twentieth century. Muslims refused to accept it as a good deed to free slaves?

>>…other thing is that it was a trend to have wealth and women of a loser....read it in the ancient history<<

Did not your prophet come to correct the wrongs of society. What was the purpose in having a new prophet if all he did was allow the bad old customs like slavery, rape and enslavement of captured women and taking of booty? Saddam was a loser so are you justifying the loot of Iraqi oil and other wealth. Is it alright for American soldiers to keep Iraqi women as concubines or sell them in Saudi Arabia? Arabs were losers against Israel so why are Muslims screaming about Israelis taking over Arab land and shooting down insurgent Arabs?

regards

Plato

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".