Our dear Aamir and what point did I miss?

Submitted by dhimmi no more (United States), Sep 19, 2007 at 07:31

You wrote this little gem

"You missed what I was trying to say. anyways, If you cannot understand I cant help you."

Then try me again.

"My point was simple the "God of Jews" , the "God of Christians" and "Allah of Muslim" are same"

One word: Bogus. and do you know why? Because:

1. The Qur'an says the God of ahl al-kitab is wahid or one and the God of the Muslims is wahid or one and it does not say that the God of ahl al-kitab and Muslims are nafsu al-wahid or the same one (God that is)

2. If you have the same God as the Christians then congratulations our dear Aamir but your Allah is Jesus but this is what the Qur'an really says.

3. And if we are to believe the poor and wannabe historian Karen Armstrong that ahl al-kitab include your ancestors the Hindus then congratulations our dear Aamir but Rama and Krishna are your Allah too and because Islam is the religion of the arabs only then who is really your Rasul?

"...We dont believe in Trinity because its not at all valid theory according to Islam..."

And which Trinity is this? is it your Allah bogus Trinity: Allah, Jesus and Mary(sic)? Or is it the real Christian Trinity of God, Jesus and the Holy Spirit? and where would I find in the Qur'an that your Allah has no like for such Trinity of God,Jesus and the Holy Spirit?

"I was also trying to say that Muslims cannot humiliate any of the Prophets because its compulsory to believe in all prophets of Allah/God..Jesus, Moses and all prior prophets are of utmost importance for us..and we cannot claim to be muslim if we say a single word against them.."

Gobbledygook and bogus. Your allah calls the Jews khanazeer wa quruud and he accuses them of being polytheists (sic) (Q9:30) and he denigrates Christian doctrines and he asks you to go out and kill polytheists and fight ahl al-kitab and then you tell me the above nonsnese? shame on you

"On the other hand Jews and Christians are constantly involved in character assasination of prophets.."

Are you talking about Abul Qasim here? Well he was a caravan raider and an Arabian warlord and when he was 53 years old he married a 6 year old girl and he ordered the killing of a female poet that was suckling her baby. I'm not telling anything that you would not find in Ibn Ishaq so what is your problem?

"Quran gave respect to all prophet because they deserve that..."

But the Qur'an does not give respect to Christians and Jews and hidus and Buddhists and atheists and women and blacks! This is what count our dear Aamir and not respect to the so called peophets that more than likely never existed

Did you ever wonder how come your Allah have no mention of your ancestors the Hindus and Buddhists unless your Allah was nothing but a local Arabian deity and the Ramadan fast is more evidence that Allah was indeed no more than Hubal the old Arabian deity

I dont know why you people deliberately ignore the good and positive points of Islam...

Positive points of Islam? Really? Could you provide me with one or two examples?

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".