RE: Plato

Submitted by Bilal (United Kingdom), Sep 13, 2009 at 13:18

After gleaming through the tedious copying and pastings that made up the overwhelming bulk of your post, I'll reply with a concise one.

1.) If Bush was following the advice of Muhammad, then he would have killed all the Jews in Israel; as we will do one day soon, because they are the filthy sons of pigs and monkeys. The fact kaafirs are naturally liars is proven by the lies that Bush has been caught out with the run-up to the war, such as "WMDs". So this in itself proves this point.

2.) The hadd for rape is capital punishment; and rape is not synonymous with adultery. I yawn at the overused cunning tactic of trying to apply the conditions of accusing one of adultery to that of rape. Is that the best you can do? As for Pakistani law; that does not constitute Shari'ah law. If you didn't know there is a war being waged in Pakistan between that of the man-made law rulers and those Taliban militants fighting for Shari'ah law. So for you to quote from man-made law in injustice to rape victims is in fact attacking your own sphere of a legal system. Your foot must look like swiss cheese the amount you've shot yourself in it by now.

3.) So in other words, you concede that a woman gets raped once every 2 minutes in the West as opposed to allegedly once every 2 hours in Pakistan. In other words, you admit the statistics of rape are explosive in comparison to a Muslim country. Very good.

4.) In your hadith quoting 'Ali, I fail to see the word "rape" in there. Therefore it wasn't rape. What I don't fail to see though, is the fact that you can't deny the fact US soldiers rape women in Abu Ghraib and elsewhere; and now they're living in a cushy jail with free bed and breakfast protected from retribution. This is what your law and society encourages; and that is why there is a rape once every 2 minutes in the West.

As for mentioning 'Aisha, Safia and so on. These unions were all done consensually as opposed to the women who get raped once every 2 minutes in the west, and the (at least one) paedophile that exists in every 10 mile radius. In the Talmud where it instructs Jewish mothers to rape their 9 year old sons, is that consensual? Or how about the Rabbis that encourage each other to molest 3 year olds? Or how about the Bible that encourages daughters to get their father drunk then to molest him? Or how about the Hindu concept of Sati, whereby the wife torches herself alive on her husband's cremation. Are those things consensual?

5.) So in other words you concede that Misyar is a form of marriage? And you concede that western whores in bars who spread their legs for the first man who buys her 1 barcardi and coke is not marriage? Speaks for itself.

6.) In Islaam the hadd for the rapist is either capital punishment or amputation of the arms and legs from opposite sides. Anything else you are referring to is based on your model of law; i.e. man-made law. Of course you didn't deny the story of Abeer Qasim al-Janabi; because it's true. And this heinous crime is typical of what stems out of you cancers of the globe, and that is why you must all be eradicated.

7.) In Shar'iah law the hadd for homosexuality is capital punishment. Yet NAMBLA in the USA are pushing for legal homosexual intercourse between adult men and male minors. This is western values. By the way. Pakistan is not based on Islamic values. If it was, Pakistan wouldn't be at war with the Mujahideen. Rather their legal values represents that of the west. So these disgusting accusations you are making reflects your own values essentially.

8.) So you affirm the Iraq - Iran war was engineered by the west. Very good.

9.) So you affirm the thousands of deaths committed by Jews; whilst at the same time ironically crying about the holocaust fallacy. Hitler should have finished the job. The world would undoubtedly be a better place.

10.) About 2 million have been killed in Iraq since 2003 alone due to a direct result of the US invasion of it. I see your rant did not dispel that fact. Therefore everything I have clamped you with thus still substatitates the notion that you are a cancer that must be subject to a caesarian from existence.

11.) Forget moderates. As far as Islamists are concerned, the leaders are all apostates and hence any of those people who fulfil the profile of their muscle can not be correlated with Islamism. Regardless, the Janjaweed are merely following the western example of invading innocent peoples' homelands and committing acts of genocide. Just like as is being done in Iraq, Palestine, Afghanistan, Chechnya, etc.

12.) The Jews of Banu Quraiza violated a covenant of security that had previously been made in pact with the Muslims. Their treason justified the end result. Treason in western armies in times of war over history resulted in execution too. I fail to see the problem. By the way, use a bidet. You kaafirs stink. I guess that's natural, too.

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".