Our dear Ahemd Khota admits that he cannot porvide us with evidence that Muhammad's little trip to Jerusalem really happened

Submitted by dhimmi no more (United States), Aug 12, 2008 at 07:52

Our dear Ahemd Khota wrote

>You will not get any proof, on the Prophet Muhammad's trip from Makkah to Jerusalem and then onto the Heavens. We do not have a movie on the event.

So I will not find it on CNN or al-Jazeera? But you know what? It never happened because such a story was plagiarized from the Zoroastrian book Arta Viraf buraq and all

>Using your logic, since no proof exists for you, you rubbish it and reject it.

Yes I do reject it as real history!

>Well, no proof exists for Moses parting the Red Sea, Exodus, Israelites etc..,

There is no historical evidence that the Exodus took place and in the words of Redford

"on the morrow of the exodus Israel numbered approximately 2.5 million (extrapolated from Num 1:46) yet the entire population of Egypt at the time was only 3 to 4.5 million. the effect on egypt must have been cataclysmic loss of servile population pillaging of gold and silver (Exod 3:21-22, 12:31-36) destruction of an army yet at no point in the history of the country during the New Kingdom is there the slightest hint of the truamatic impact such event would have had on economics or society"

>It can therefore, safely be said that , you rubbish and reject the Jewish belief too.

Mr. ignorant there is a difference bewteen history as in "what really happened" and what historians call heilsgeschichte. And no I do not translate German for ignorant people like you.

The story of the exodus is not real history but it is heilsgeschichte! You have no clue about what I'm talking about do you?

Now Muslims tell us that the story of Exodus is real history and not heilsgeschichte. See what happens when you plagiarize the sacred stories of other people?

>So according to You, , since there's no proof, Moses did not exist,parting of the Red Sea did not exist,

Oh are you also aware that the first five books of the Bible did not drop from the skies but were written over several hundered years by 5 different hands and the most famous of them is the so called P tradition and this is no secret (see Wellhausen's prolegomena) you see our dear Ahemd no books drop from the skies and you need to start reading some real books and stop reading this poor literature called the Qur'an

>Israelites did not exist, promised land did not exist....

The jews have always been part of the Middle East from time immemorial and Israel in their land that was invaded by the Arabs in 633CE.

And there is a difference between "real history" and "heilsgeschichte" and Israel and the Jews are real people and Israel belongs to them period and the sacred history of the Jews is their sacred history. The Arabs? they can go back to where they came from and that is the Hijaz

>So according to YOU, Dhimmi, Israel does not have a right to exist...

No it is you and your likes and anti-semites like you that wish to see Israel gone.

I urge you to abandon Islam and be whole again

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".