And al-komedya al-islamiyya goes on and on

Submitted by dhimmi no more (United States), Jul 12, 2011 at 07:21

So our dear Amin the wannabe arab is it tiflan or atfalan and is it ba3da or ma3a? Let me guess you have no clue right? Shame on you

It is kutub al-turath al-islami that are telling us that these are mistakes so do you disagree with kutub al-turath al-islami? You think that I should tell the Muslim nuts in London that you our dear Amin disagrees with their books?

For the readers notice that he avoided like the plague refuting that the Quranic tiflan and ba3da are mistakes and the reason is he knows no Arabic right our dear Amin?

>There is absolutely no point going on -Dhimmi no more and to a lesser extent Nur el Masih Ben Haq - make up things when they get themselves twisted. This bogus - knowing Arabic claim. Resorting to personal insults and etc.

>If the likes of Ibn Hisham,

Ibn Hisham, is a grammarian? really? where? In your dreams? For the readers Ibn Hisham is the one that edited Ibn Ishaq's sira so could you provide us with the name of his book of grammar?

Hint: Stop your delusions

>Sibwayah

You can read sibawayhe's Kitab? Really? then how come you are not aware that

ina wa akhawatiah tar3a3 al-mubtada' wa tansub al-khabar which means that

Hadhan (sic)

Should be

Hadhayne

Yakharabi wa yalahwiti a kafir like me is fixing Allah's Arabic

>or Abu Bakr Nahwi -

Abu Bakr Nahwi? Who on earth is he? Mr ignorant Nahw means grammar

For the readers: Muslims when they have nothing to say they drop names that they have herad about from their Arab masters but read a real book? Not really

>Classical Arabic Grammarians do not know Arabic - then I wonder who does.

Stop your delusions it is real grammarians the likes of al-Suyuti that is telling us that it should be hadhayne and that the Quranic hadhan is a mistake and a lost tablighee like you knows more?

Even Uthman is asking your likes to lie and write it as hadhan but vocalize it as hadhayne

What a fadiha they are asking you to lie right?

Get absolutely EVERYTHING wrong and still holding onto it as truth - well! Wow! I am amazed.

I will leave this to the readers to judge you ...

Shame on you

>So it does not matter what I post - all Dhimmi's response is "gobbltey gook" to the bits he cannot answer back. He will change your response and quote it wrong - either deliberately or not comprehending something.

I really pity you and your likes

Obviously most people do not know Arabic on this site - so cannot judge the matter. So I rest my case ....But please read this wreck

http://www.danielpipes.org/comments/187141

The train wreck is you and your poor Muslim education

But you know what? This is an example of Arabian cultural imperialism you have to pretend to know a language that you cannot speak read or write ...

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".