Self Worthy Praises

Submitted by Amin Riaz (United Kingdom), Jul 20, 2011 at 23:14

Another pack of lies - someone who doesn't 2 things about me. You need to sort yourself out. And what is this with the self-worth rubbish?

In the above debate - you never brought up a single credible reference from Islamic Scholars after giving you enoguh chances. As-Suyuti - I answered you over that. And you had no reply. All you did was kept repeating the same thing.

Or going off into these long self-worthy self-praisng speeches. About some hypocrisy and allsorts and now look at this greek mind blah blah blah. You started the debate - and you divert away from it. Even in your closing remarks.

Never mind that - you could not even bring one single credible reference from a Western Islamic scholar on the so called mistake.

See the scholar who first came up with tis mumbo-jumbo is discredited from fellow Western scholars. One - you do not have enough knowledge of it - second - Even if you did you never mentioned anyone knowing full well I would have easily countered it,

Third - you do not have the capacity or the talent to argue.

------

Another aspect - You have no knowledge of Arabic:

You refused to converse in Arabic.

You changed my replies and reposted them. Doctoring the evidence (how basic and stupid a thing to do)

You never said where and how you studied Arabic - unlike me.

Have no knowledge of simple syntactical analysis.

Inability to reason means - you fail to understand that to prove grammar mistakes in Quran - oyu have to bring sources of Arabic beside Arabic from that era and place - then and only then you can asses the language of the Quran.

You failed to comprehend if the particle is not harf mushabbah bil fail then - there is no mistake. All you kept saying was - so what so what difference does it make. Even when I answered this - you still kept the mantra going - even though you could not reply back.

You lack ability to reason - read your own reply (http://www.danielpipes.org/comments/187478) - do you simply not understand why this is so wrong.

Refused to verify by an impartial judge. (for example : http://poemsintranslation.blogspot.com/ - an Athiest)

You have no knowledg of basic grammar elements - like subject of a verb. In the exmple of an ayat you said was a mistake - you did not even know if something was a subject or not? So how can you assess whether something is mistake or not.

No one helped you either. Oh except for green ticks :-) even then you only got no more than 3 or 4.

-----

This is called being dead buried - enjoy the position. All you are trying o do with your comments and worthy speeches is for effect and praise from an audience that is on your side ONYL because they too are anti-Muslim

Else anyone with a sense of fair play (a very British concept) would easily see why I win this one.

-----

This worthy speech of skepticism doesn't work one way sonny - it just that the Quran is probaly right - because anti-Muslim scholarship of over 400 yrs has not led to not even ONE answer that at least majority could agree upon. What one says other cancels - if one says Quranic language is assyrian someone else has countered it. If one says mistakes o Grammar - others counter it (yes - even J Wansbrough). End result cancelling each other out.

Its only recently that a few Western scholars have got together to get the story straight and to launch a unified attack. The funny thing is you would not even know who?

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".