In Memory of Ali Dashti and you can prove him wrong and another liguistic scandal in the book of Allah

Submitted by dhimmi no more (United States), Aug 7, 2011 at 08:19

You see our dear Amin whose Hindu ancestors were brutalized by Islam and Muslims you can prove that Ali Dashti was wrong about the fact that he believes that in hadhan la sahiran is a mistake and it should be in hadhayne lasahiran but like a typical Muslim you go after the wrong target! the target is that you tell us why in hadhan lasahiran is correct now do you get it?

Now let us check Ali Dashti's reading of another liguistic karitha in the Qur'an and that is Surat al-Nisa' 160 oh did I just write 160? well let us check in al-Azhar's haqa'iq al-islam fi muwajahat shubhat al-mushakekeen page 175 we are told that it is aya number 162! Same aya and why is that our dear Amin the wannabe Arab? let me help you because giving numbers to al-ayat did not drop from the sky but was editing by the ulama! So next time you repeat the bogus tablighee claim that no one touched the Qur'an since it did drop from the sky remember surat al-nisa' 160 or is it 162

Oh there is more even the names of the suras were in flux (for the readers check the name of sura 105 in al-Tabari where he calls it Surat al-lam tara and now it is called surat al-feel! More evidence that the names of the suras did not drop from the sky but was edited by the ulama that were trying to fix the liguistic disasters of the Qur'an)

Oh the mistake here is called 3atf mansub 3ala marfu3

So let us read what Ali Dashti tells us about this disaster see page 49 in Bist o seh sal

in verse 160 of sura 4 on nesaa "but those among them who are well grounded in knowledge the believers .......... and the performers of the prayer and the payers of the alms tax" the word for performers is in the accusative where it ought to be in the nominative case like the words for well grounded, believers, and payers.

ROTFL it seems that Allah has real difficulty with al-raf3 wa al-nasb or the nominative and the accustaive cases! So you see if we kuffar make mistakes then we are in good company

And do you know who is really al-nasab al-kabeer? it is he who pretends that he earned a majisteer fi al-lugha al-3arabiyya and cannot even tell that fadiha in mu'unath. Shame on you

Now it is your chance to prove that Ali dashti is wrong!

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".