What a scandal mistakes in the Qur'an

Submitted by dhimmi no more (United States), Jul 17, 2011 at 06:24

It is silly when our dear Amin debates a language that he cannot speak read or write

>This is worse than BBC repeats.

If you do not like the BBC then leave England and good riddance

قالوا - verb and subject ان nafiah liljins negation (of genus) particle هذان demonstrative pronoun ل exceptive particle - the negative and exceptive particles imply restriction - this is very in common classical arabic to use particles like that - heaache to translate in english - especially formaing positive sentences and meaning with double negation.

Qalu means they said so what? and in tanfi al-jins or nafia lel jins what jins? where do I find it in sibawyahe's definition of in wa akhawtiha? you tell and where is the jins? and what does this have to do with the fact that hadhan should be hadhayne you tell us mr Einstein

Here is the answer - so why isn't Dhimmi - able to answer?

My answer is you are clueless now do you get it

>His one attempt left him with even more errors that is why.

What attempt that you have no clue we know that

وأما قوله تعالى‏:‏ إن هذان لساحران فيمن أضمر لأن لو جعل إن بمعنى نعم فإنه أدخل اللام على خبر المبتدأ لأن هذان في قولهما ابتداء واللام لا تدخل على خبر الابتداء وإنما تدخل على المبتدأ وإدخالها على الخبر شاذ وأنشدوا فيه‏:‏ أم الحليس لعجوز شهر به ترضى من اللحم بعظم الرقبة وقد تقدم ما هو الاختيار عندنا‏.‏

>Suyuti - the person Dhimmi actually praised in a funny way.

Did you read my tabreer al-khata' and did you understand it? and let me tell you what he is saying

wa ;ima qawlahu in hadhan lasahiran fi man admar li an laaw ja3ala in bima3na na3am (see my explanations of al-tabreer) adkhal al-lam 3ala al-khabar al-mubtada' (see my tabreer) li ana hadhan fi qalwlihuma ibtida' al-lam la tadkhul a3la khabar al-ibtida' wa inama tadkhul 3ala al-ibtida' wa adkhaliha 3ala al-khabar shadh wa inshudu feeh blah blah blah

Did you really understand what he is saying? Let me guess you have no clue and where would i find your strange nafiah (sic) lel jins in the above? you will not find it whay the delusions?

-------

So why create an post a BOGUS scnadal. if Dhimmi knew Arabic - he would have replied to this by now.

Reply to what? about your bogus tanfiah lel jins or nafiah or what ever? and what does this have to do with the fact that Hadhan should be hadhayne you tell us

I do not see anything in tabreerat al-khata' that has anything to do with your bogus nafiah lel jins

Stop your delusions

-----

So far none else has come to his defence either - well no one good - Michel Zala - tried and backed down after being beaten.

Oh the Muslim ego!

Oh well....

I urge you to leave islam and go and see tabeeb nafsi you need help big time

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".