Masood: Conquests are with the blessings of Allah

Submitted by Plato (India), Nov 30, 2008 at 02:18

Masood, you wrote:

>>If , we look at history, all Holy Lands of all Religions have been occupied by Muslims.<<

You seem extraordinarily proud of the fact that Muslims conquered the holy lands of all religions. Why then do you complain when other religions conquer Muslim lands. Palestine for instance. Or Chechnya. Or Al Andalus. Is it because Allah has ordered Muslims to make it victorious over all other religions (3:85, 8:39, 9:111). The other religions have no such requirement and so you don't find them going out of their way to slaughter Muslims to occupy Mecca and Medina.

>> But not Macca and Medina, the Religious centre of Muslims with bless of GOD.

Why, even with so much sophisticated weapons and advanced technology, non-muslim are still unable to break even one claim of Mohammad that no non-muslim can enter in his land (Mecca and Medina ) as victorious.<<

Mr. Plato.. Is this not great blessing and truth about Islam.<<

It is the truth that Mecca and Medina have not been occupied by other religions. Have you thought beyond the nonsense that the madrassa teaches you? Recall that the prophet and his four favourite companions were not even bones in their graves before the succeeding Muslims had abandoned Mecca and Medina for better places. If Muslims themselves abandoned them for better places why would any invader be silly enough to raid them when there are richer pickings elsewhere.

If there had been a few barrels of oil under the sand there the black stone would have been rolled over to make way for an oil rig. No one wants to waste his time conquering sand and rock. That is the truth and the blessing of Allah which kept invaders away from the rock He ejected from heaven.

>>One day with bless of God you wil accept Islam. Amen.

Thanks<<

Aameen, to that. But remember Allah has fixed my fate even before I was born. I will never be blessed by Allah.

>>Mr. Plato… so why those Mongols converted to Islam and the same attackers on Islamic world became the defenders of great Islamic territories. << >>

Mr.Masood your madrassa has censored a lot of world history. Have you heard of the Roman Empire. The Christians claim they were persecuted and battered by the Romans. The same Romans became the greatest defenders of Christianity. And just to remind you if your maulana forgot about it some of the successors to the Roman Empire completely decimated the Muslims in
Andalus. Muslim Spain was the brightest jewel in Islamic history. Muslims weep over its loss to this day.

>>You don't know, same muslim mongoles have been ruled over India too for centuries. But how can we know that who is really blessed by God.<<

Muslims, Mongols and others ruled India for nearly 700 years with devastating effects on its people and culture. The Buddhist religion practically disappeared from the place of its birth. The great university of Nalanda was completely destroyed and its teachers beheaded. Milllions (Will Durant the historian estimates it was one of the most barbaric invasions ever) were killed and enslaved.

Regards

Plato

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".