Point? What point?

Submitted by dhimmi no more (United States), Apr 12, 2010 at 18:12

Our dear iamjoseph who needs to work on his ideas wrote

>My point here is, the Arab race is post-500 BCE.

You have a point? masha'allah

Hello: Arguement from silence is a poor argument

But wait: you told us that there were no Arabic and Arabs before 400CE or did you forget?

>Re. Where did they come from is hardly the issue; the issue is of an identfiable group, not that Arabs are generic to the regions.

Oh let me guess" you have some cockamamie theory about the "Arabs"! Oh spare us this one

> There are ancient nations and relatively new nations.

Oh and "new nations"! Wa minkun nasrafeed

>There was no Jewish/Hebrew nation or race pre-4000 years ago; there was no Arab nation/race pre-2500 years ago.

So?

>The Jewish nation/race is far older than the Arab one,

So?

>as are a host of others in this region.

And?

>This is evidenced by the vaccuum of Arabs pre-500 BCE;

Hint: argument from silence!

no ancient Hebrew/Monotheist belief of Arabs till Islam emerged;

So?

>no evidence Moses was a Muslim by 'belief'

Hello: If Muslims claim that Moses or that you and I were born Muslims then you just laugh after all who cares

> [the reverse applies here].

What reverse? Muhammad was Jewish? Sobhanallah

> In modern history, all the states created by Briton and Europe are based on fiction,

So?

> aside from the reality of oil reserves and its corruption. Iraq is made as Arab, when Babylon was not Arab - so go figure.

And your point is?

>The Arabs learnt of Abraham, Moses and Monotheism not from any Mohammed but from Jews,

So what?

> a 1000 years before Islam emerged - no other way could they have known of Abraham and Moses but for the Hebrew bible [first translated after Greece invaded Arabia],

The Greeks invaded Arabia? When?

> and by being with Jews after the Babylonian exile. Just as the Muslim Arabs dumped a Mosque on the known Jewish sites - the pre-Islamic Arabs first emerged as gangs who offered protection against foreign [Greek] invaders. They started this protection facility in Egypt, then took over the Coptics. It is proven by Islamic doctrines to TAKE OVER other peoples' lands all over the globe. E.g. India and Palestine. The Muslims are today spreading a false history and barring any real history in its states. And not a single brave, honest Muslim questions it: what does that say? I am of course open to any proof which can negate my statements.

Whatever

Ya habibi you need to work on your ideas is this asking for much?

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".