And more ignorance

Submitted by dhimmi no more (United States), Apr 24, 2010 at 06:24

This is what I wrote

>Our dear Iam who has no clue what is really EA or no clue if it is a language or a dialect and who told us that there were really no Arabs or Arabic language before 400CE then when he was reminded about Herodotus' Arabs he changed his bogus claim to 500BCE! Oh the Arabs of the Periplus? God forbid he has no clue what is really the Periplus! And when he was provided with evidence that we have Arabic language inscriptions in let us say Qaryat al-Faw dated to 300BCE he just avoided dealing with this factI call this dishonesty

This is our dear iam al-ghalabawi's answer

># I call it historically evidenced facts which you are unable to negate.

Gobbeldygook

>None of your examples give any evidence whatsover that the Arab race existed pre-500 BCE - the names you quote in your examples are not of ARABS,

Hello: They were Assyrians

>the reason we see no evdences of any transit imprints of an Arab king, nation, city, monument or anything seen in all other race's histories.

you need to read Hoyland's book about EXTANT historical evidence we have about the Arabs from the bronze age to the coming of islam and there is plenty of it

And you know what? ...you seem to be unaware of the so called "argument from silence" But again I pity you

>You have also misquoted the Hebrew bible by changing ARABIAN to ARAB.

Hello: Write to Hoyland and tell him that his translation is wrong and you will be making a fool of yourself and I do not translate Hebrew but the word Must be Arab and not Arabian because this is English grammar. See I told you your English is poor

>You have provided no counter evidence that Arabic writings came around 400 CE.

Hello: We have inscriptions in Arabic from al-Faw 300BCE!! Go and check them

>There is no such thing Egyptian Arabic -

Hello: there was no EA before 642CE because this is when the Arabs invaded Egypt and only fools would deny that there is such thing as EA

> its just a means tio manipulate history because there is no evidences of your claims, even proven by your own admission Islamic Arabs invaded Egypt in the 6th C - namely it is stolen from the pre-Arab Coptics who are totally persecuted today - while questioning the historical and factual rights of the Jews.

The one that is ignorant of what history is all about is you

But What does this have to do that EA is a reality like or not?

>The Jews, kurds and Coptics pre-date the Arab race; so does Greece and Persia. But we don't see a total vaccuum of their history as we do of the Arab race pre-500BCE.

OK what does this have to do with EA being a lugha or a lahja?

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".