If somebody is humiliated does it mean he is right?

Submitted by Susan (Canada), Mar 6, 2007 at 23:44

Submitted by A Muslim, Feb 2, 2007 at 17:08

Wrong is heaped upon the Muslims today from all around. We are humiliated and tortured by people like yourself. Does that mean all Muslims are wrong? No, what it instead means is that you and your anti-Islam campaign is wrong. And, one day justice will be brought to your doorstep.

You are using bad logic here. Just because JESUS was humiliated and was right, doeas not mean that every humiliated person is right. Some people bring their humiliation upon themselves justly. If I do something wrong than I may expect humiliation, like Hitler and Naci Germany, they were humiliated justly at the end of the war. Also Communists were humiliated when the iron curtain fell after many years of monopoly on power. And just because they were humiliated they were not right. Maybe before you jump to conclusions look for the reasons of humiliation if you feel humiliated.

Yes, I agree there are some so called Muslims who bring disrepute to Islam but, the disrepute that Christians have brought upon themselves is beyond comparison. Hitler killed 6 million Jews. Was he a Muslim? Was it an Islamic country that bombed Japan? Was it an Islamic country that waged war against Vietnam? Did the Muslims encourage and spread slavery in Africa? Were the holy Crusades carried out by Muslims? Was the native Indian population in the Americas wiped out by Muslims? Were the native Aborigines in Australia annihilated by the Muslims? Look in your own dirty wardrobe before you talk nonsense.

Here is another problem with logic, if somebody was not muslim, you imply that that person was Christian.
How many Hindus were killed in India by Moslim warriors shouting Allah Akbar? How about Banu Qurayza, how about Armenians who were almost completely wiped out of Turkey in the name of Allah? Hitler you use as one of your examples is known to say when somebody was objecting to his killing of Jews " Who remembered Aremenians?"

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".