this is a comedy show right now ngl

Submitted by Hamzah (United Arab Emirates), Dec 29, 2021 at 02:58

Well, mr. full of knowledge has made claims that Islam is for Arabs and meant for Arabs ONLY!

What a stupid claim!

Yes, Muhammed didn't come to India, nor could he speak Hindi, but there probably was another messenger sent to India to spread the message of Islam, hence creating the chain of Muslims in India, and when did Abdul Hadi EVER SAY that it is completely verified information??, lets revisit what he said

>Talking about the prophet sent to India, many Muslims believe that Buddha was actually a prophet whose original name was Dhul Kifl, it's not verified in any way though. It's not even close to the truth, but it sure is an assumption.

NOT VERIFIED IN ANY WAY; NOT CLOSE TO THE TRUTH, BUT IT SURE IS AN ASSUMPTION.

Later on, he made it clear that he doesn't believe in it and just said it for your information that CERTAIN Muslims believe that he was a prophet.

...I ALREADY MADE IT CLEAR THAT IT IS NOT VERIFIED NOR IS IT CLEAR IN ANY WAY. I DON'T EVEN BELIEVE IN IT, YOU ALWAYS MISINTERPRET STUFF AND THEN CALL ME OUT FOR IT, SO ANNOYING.

This is what he wrote when your...brain thought he actually made the statement, like seriously...?

Now, we don't clearly know nor did any Hadith or verse in the Qur'an verify who all those 124,000 prophets (some people say its 140,000, but whatever) actually are. And Muhammed SAW was sent to the Arabs speaking the Arabic language. Surely some other prophet was sent to India and he spoke Sanskrit, Hindi or something. But what we do know is that there wasn't a prophet sent to any place or tribe that came after Muhammed, Muhammed was the very last of them all.

No, Muhammed wasn't sent to Hindu ancestors, nor does the Qur'an claim it, but look at how many Muslims are there out of Arabia. Look at the influence of Islam in countries like Indonesia, Malaysia etc. Islam is not meant for Arabs at all, so prithee don't bring this up again.

I dont se anything wrong in 10:47, I dont know if you are mentioning 13:8 or 8:13.

13:8 just talks about something not controversial at all

8:13 talks about how Allah will put in hellfire anyone who denies him and his religion. Isn't that most of the religions? do good, heaven, do bad, hell.

And Muslims clearly accept that we don't know more than just a small fraction of messengers that were sent by Allah to the earth.

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".